5 Criminally Underrated Psychological Thriller TV Shows You Need To Watch

by

There are tons of crime and suspense shows available, but many excellent ones don’t get the attention they deserve – it’s just unavoidable. Not every series becomes a social media hit, and the streaming algorithms can bury even well-made shows. That’s why there are so many ‘forgotten’ psychological thrillers out there – the ones with gripping stories, tense atmospheres, and complex characters that immediately pull you in. If you’re a fan of the genre, you’ve probably overlooked some real hidden gems.

These five psychological thriller shows demonstrate why the genre remains so captivating. They didn’t get the attention they deserved, but each offers a compelling story you’ll regret missing.

5) The Watcher

When *The Watcher* was released, it surprised many viewers. Considering it came from the creator of *American Horror Story* and *Monster*, people anticipated a high-quality show. Though some found it leaned more towards drama than a suspenseful crime thriller-and it became something of a running joke-the series is actually quite compelling. It centers on a family who move into a lovely New Jersey home and begin receiving unsettling letters from an anonymous, fixated neighbor. What starts as a straightforward true-crime premise quickly develops into a story about mounting paranoia, loneliness, and eroding trust.

The show received a mixed reaction, largely because it doesn’t offer easy answers. However, that ambiguity is actually its strength, effectively portraying the unsettling feeling of being constantly watched. *The Watcher* is a thriller that avoids simple resolutions, and that’s likely why it hasn’t gotten the recognition it deserves. While some viewers found the lack of a definitive ending frustrating, the show’s focus on psychological tension is more impactful than many realize.

4) Castle Rock

Let’s be honest, *Castle Rock* deserved a larger audience. The show, inspired by many of Stephen King’s stories, is both inventive and captivating. It skillfully weaves together characters and references from King’s world, but instead of simply retelling old tales, it crafts a completely new story. Presented as an anthology series, the first season centers on lawyer Henry Deaver (André Holland) who returns to his hometown and encounters a puzzling prisoner, unleashing a wave of hidden secrets. It’s a real gem for Stephen King enthusiasts, but even for those unfamiliar with his work, it’s one of the most compelling shows on television.

I honestly don’t get why more people aren’t talking about *Castle Rock*. I think a lot of fans went in expecting a show packed with references and Easter eggs, and when it didn’t deliver that immediately, they were let down. But that’s what makes it so good! It’s not about hitting you over the head with fan service; it’s all about creating a really creepy, unsettling mood. It’s a thriller that gets under your skin, playing with things like memory and how the past haunts you. It builds tension in every single scene using psychological horror. It’s not flawless, but it’s easily one of the best adaptations of Stephen King’s work, and it deserves to be recognized for how bravely different it is.

3) The Sinner

Though it initially appears to be a typical crime drama, *The Sinner* is actually much deeper than that. Each season of this anthology series begins with a seemingly normal person committing a shocking crime, and Detective Harry Ambrose (Bill Pullman) investigates the hidden reasons behind their actions. The first season is particularly impactful: a woman unexpectedly kills a stranger in public, and the truth behind it is far more unsettling than anyone could imagine. It’s a truly captivating show – it’s no surprise it generated so much excitement when it first came out.

Initially, this show was highly regarded, but it gradually became less noticed and, consequently, undervalued. It lacked sensational marketing and avoided excessive violence or constant thrills. However, this is precisely what sets it apart. Unlike most crime shows that focus on *who* committed the crime, this one delves into *why* – which can make the pace feel slower. It’s rare to find a crime show that consistently examines themes like trauma, memory, and guilt, making it a truly psychological thriller centered on the complexities of the human mind. It’s definitely worth your time.

2) The Devil’s Hour

You’re missing out if you haven’t seen *The Devil’s Hour*. It’s a truly excellent show with a fascinating concept: Lucy (Jessica Raine) is a woman plagued by strange visions every night at 3:33 AM, and she’s also caught in a complex and increasingly chaotic police investigation. It’s a compelling blend of crime thriller, psychological drama, and supernatural elements, all supported by sharp, intelligent writing.

Slow-burn stories aren’t for everyone, but they’re common in psychological thrillers, which need time to build suspense. Thankfully, *The Devil’s Hour* isn’t boring at all. It’s a clever thriller that gradually reveals clues and information, creating a big payoff in the end. It makes you question everything you think you know. The show didn’t gain much attention, likely because many people simply haven’t discovered it yet. However, if you enjoy psychological thrillers, this one is definitely worth watching.

1) Ripley

If you’re familiar with *The Talented Mr. Ripley*, the new series *Ripley* is arguably even more compelling. It demonstrates that adaptations can be incredibly successful, even when based on well-known stories. The show follows Tom Ripley (Andrew Scott), a swindler tasked with bringing a wealthy man’s son back from Italy. What seems like a straightforward assignment soon descends into a web of jealousy, deceit, and violence. This version, unlike the film starring Matt Damon, takes the time to deeply explore Ripley’s mind, and it does so with remarkable skill.

Ripley often gets overlooked, and that’s the main reason it’s underrated. People simply dismissed it as just another retelling of the story. But honestly, it’s a remarkably well-done adaptation of Patricia Highsmith’s work. While it’s not a quick-paced show, and the black and white filming style might seem unusual, those choices perfectly create the chilling and calculating atmosphere the story needs. It’s a brilliant example of how to build suspense without relying on tired tropes, and it’s easily one of the best thrillers ever created for television.

https://comicbook.com/marvel/news/hbo-max-thrillers-hidden-recommendation-september-2025/embed/#

Read More

2025-09-27 04:12