Dick Grayson Should Still Be Batman

by

Over the years, many characters have donned the Batman costume, but fans have always understood that they were simply holding the position until Bruce Wayne returned. Characters like the volatile Jean-Paul Valley and the dependable Jim Gordon have worn the cape, each with their unique place in the storyline. However, no one has ever embodied the essence of Batman as effectively as Bruce. That is, except for one individual. Following Bruce’s apparent death in Infinite Crisis, Dick Grayson took up the mantle. Instead of merely filling in for Batman, Dick transformed the character and gave it a fresh, needed perspective. I adore Bruce as Batman, but if Dick continued in this role, he might have surpassed Bruce’s version of Batman.

Dick Was Made to Be Batman

From the onset of his career as Robin, it was always expected that Dick Grayson would one day take over as Batman from Bruce Wayne. This expectation persisted until Dick distanced himself from Bruce and ceased being Robin. The arrival of Jason Todd, other subsequent Robins, and Dick’s own hero identity as Nightwing disrupted these plans. By the 1990s, the relationship between Bruce and Dick had significantly deteriorated to a point where Bane, when he broke Bruce’s back, felt it inappropriate to ask Dick to once again step into the shadows as Batman. However, after their reconciliation during their joint efforts to stop Jean-Paul, the “Prodigal” storyline unfolded, with Dick assuming the role of Batman while Bruce reevaluated his life. This period felt like a homecoming not just because Dick was back in Bruce’s good books but as a sign that he would eventually inherit the mantle of the Dark Knight.

As a die-hard DC comics fan, I must confess, Dick Grayson cherished his role as Nightwing dearly. He had devoted countless hours to carve out his own identity, beyond being Batman’s ex-Robin. Nightwing, today, stands tall among the elite DC superheroes, a testament to his success in his mission.

However, even though Dick had no desire to replace Batman and honored Bruce Wayne’s wish in his will not to take up the mantle, when the time came for a new Dark Knight, he stepped forward courageously. Dick donned the cape and cowl, not just filling Batman’s shoes but redefining the essence of the hero entirely. His portrayal of Batman was nothing short of extraordinary.

Dick Evolved Batman

In the leadership of Bruce, the Batman persona symbolized fear rather than hope. He aimed to rescue Gotham City by spreading terror among its criminal minds, achieving this effectively, yet never truly finding comfort in his endeavor as a beacon of hope. For Bruce, he fostered hope by demonstrating how one could transform pain into progress, making him a hero who thrives on hope, but Dick surpassed Bruce in this aspect.

Dick not only preserved the fearsome image Batman instills in cowardly criminals, but he did so without causing public apprehension. Dick masterfully combined inspiring fear and admiration in the hearts of Gotham’s citizens and beyond, a feat that Bruce could never have envisioned, thereby elevating Batman to an even higher level.

Dick shares the same skill set as Bruce, and Bruce’s influence is evident in everything Dick does. However, Dick’s perspective and approach to problems introduced a freshness into Batman narratives that was unattainable with Bruce. Reading tales featuring Dick Grayson as Batman offered a captivating blend of novelty and familiarity, striking a balance between the old and the new without alienating audiences yearning for either.

Through his inheritance, Dick assuming the role of Batman elevated the Caped Crusader beyond being merely another superhero. Instead, Batman transformed into a legacy, an enduring name symbolizing the unyielding guardian of the innocent. This shift imbued Batman with a sense of grandeur, as if we were witnessing the unfolding of a new chapter in his saga, the beginning of an epic tale. Even when Bruce returned to take up the mantle once more, Dick chose not to relinquish it. Instead, he was encouraged to continue embodying Batman, thereby allowing Bruce to introduce the concept of Batman on a global scale with Batman Incorporated. Under Dick’s leadership, Batman grew to be more than ever before.

Regrettably, we only experienced a minimal amount of time with Dick as Batman prior to the New 52 reboot, which returned him to being Nightwing. I adore both characters, and they are among my all-time favorite heroes. However, it’s hard to argue against the fact that Dick brought something unique to the Batman persona that Bruce couldn’t quite capture. Dick managed to breathe new life into the character, and we barely scratched the surface of what could have been an incredible narrative journey before he was taken away from us. I would love to see Dick step into the role permanently in future stories, as it’s clear that Dick Grayson has what it takes to be just as much Batman as Bruce.

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/batman-vehicles-ranked/embed/#

Read More

2025-07-07 17:43