Game of the Year Is Going to Be Impossible This Time

by

2025 is shaping up to be an amazing year for video games, with a huge number of highly anticipated releases. The competition for Game of the Year is already intense, and it’s happening earlier than usual. We’re looking at potentially the most competitive year ever, making it really hard to pick a winner. From creative indie games to big-budget sequels, developers are pushing the limits of what games can be, delivering incredible stories and immersive experiences. It truly feels like a golden age for gaming.

It’s incredibly difficult to choose just six Game of the Year nominees when so many recent releases are exceptional. Honestly, it feels almost unfair to the developers! Who knew there could be too many great games? 2025 is shaping up to be a fantastic year for gaming, and that’s all thanks to the dedication of so many talented developers.

A Year Overflowing With Masterpieces

This year’s top game contenders all push boundaries in storytelling, gameplay, or artistic design. Among them, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 has emerged as a standout surprise. Developed by Sandfall Interactive, this visually stunning RPG boasts innovative gameplay with a turn-based combat system that feels dynamic and engaging. As a brand new game, it’s quickly become a major player alongside the industry’s most established titles.

The sequel to Hideo Kojima’s popular and unique game, Death Stranding 2: On the Beach, is finally here. It’s even more unusual and thought-provoking than the first, but also surprisingly focused on human connection. Kojima continues to blend storytelling and gameplay seamlessly, creating an experience that’s both deeply moving and intellectually stimulating. While the story might be complex for some, the compelling gameplay and immersive atmosphere make it a strong contender for Game of the Year.

Hades II is a strong contender for game of the year. Supergiant Games, known for the popular indie game Hades, has delivered a fantastic sequel. Currently the highest-rated game on Metacritic, Hades II revitalizes the roguelike genre, making each playthrough feel important and exciting, all while immersing players in a world of Greek mythology. The new main character, Melinoe, is quickly winning fans with her witty personality and smooth fighting style, much like the original hero, Zagreus.

Okay, so after years of waiting, we finally got our hands on Hollow Knight: Silksong and honestly, it was worth it. Team Cherry really knocked it out of the park – it feels like Hollow Knight, but in so many exciting, new ways. The way the character moves, the combat, and the art style are all top-notch. I’ve seen some debate about how hard it is, but trust me, it’s a challenge you’ll enjoy – and it was definitely worth the wait!

Blue Prince is a surprising contender, even more so than Clair Obscur. It’s a rare independent game that unexpectedly pushes the boundaries of storytelling. With its surreal atmosphere and constantly changing environments, it’s one of the most inventive puzzle-adventure games we’ve seen lately. While it might be considered a long shot, Blue Prince definitely has a shot at winning Game of the Year, which would be a fantastic addition to the existing physical copy of Red Prince.

Why Choosing a Winner Feels Impossible

Choosing a Game of the Year winner in 2025 is difficult not because there aren’t good games, but because everyone has a different idea of what makes a game great. Some players want innovation, others prioritize emotional connection, and many simply want a game that’s fun and offers lots of replay value. The gaming industry has evolved to the point where ‘excellence’ isn’t one-size-fits-all. This year’s top contenders all offer unique and compelling approaches to storytelling and creating immersive experiences.

Choosing a Game of the Year winner has become more complex over time. It’s no longer simply about how well a game is made. Now, a game’s impact on culture and how people connect with it are also important. In fact, releasing a game when it will have the biggest impact can be crucial. Players and critics now consider things like how a game made them feel and what kind of conversations it sparked when deciding on their Game of the Year.

Deciding which game is ‘Game of the Year’ isn’t about finding the best game overall. It’s about recognizing creativity, emotional impact, skillful design, ambition, and everything else that makes games special. Because all the nominees are strong in different ways, no single game excels in every area. Each contender deserves to win for its own unique strengths, but only one will be chosen this year.

Who Actually Has the Best Shot?

It’s tough to pick a clear winner because all these games are excellent. Right now, Hades II seems to be leading the pack. It was very popular even when it was still in development, and that success has continued now that it’s fully released – critics and players alike are loving it. It’s polished, emotionally engaging, and you can play it again and again. However, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 is a newcomer that’s truly striking and memorable. It has the potential to become a huge hit, much like Baldur’s Gate 3 did last year.

Hideo Kojima is a highly respected creator, and if award judges prioritize originality and meaningful themes, Death Stranding 2: On the Beach has a strong chance of winning. However, Hollow Knight: Silksong is likely to be a fan favorite. After a seven-year wait, it’s become a legendary game, and its release has exceeded expectations.

The independent game Blue Prince adds to a thriving indie scene. Smaller, independently developed games are increasingly demonstrating that they can compete with big-budget blockbusters in terms of story and unique ideas. However, even when nominated, indie titles rarely win Game of the Year awards. With so many excellent games released this year, it’s fair to question whether this makes it even harder for them to win.

It’s hard to pick a clear winner this year. The true success stories are the games that consistently delivered huge hits. The competition for Game of the Year is incredibly close, and any game that wins will have truly earned it – many other deserving titles could easily have taken the prize.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

Read More

2025-11-04 03:11