20 Years Later, Fans Still Can’t Rewatch the Gilmore Girls Episode That Fumbled 1 of the Best Characters

by

It’s rare for a TV show to have a final season as underwhelming as Season 7 of Gilmore Girls. After the show’s creator, Amy Sherman-Palladino, departed following Season 6, the series drastically changed its feel, lost much of its charm, and negatively impacted several characters, including Luke, Rory, and Lane. Although Season 7 is widely considered the show’s weakest, one character’s decline actually began before Sherman-Palladino’s departure.

Emily Gilmore, first seen in the very first episode, is known as Lorelai’s demanding mother. While she frequently interfered, her motivations usually came from a good place, making her a sympathetic character. After Lorelai ran away following the birth of her daughter, Emily had minimal contact with her granddaughter for many years and desperately wanted to reconnect with both of them. However, in this Season 5 episode, she does something so shocking that it completely undermines all the growth she’d shown throughout the series.

Wedding Bell Blues Showed A Different Side to Emily Gilmore

Throughout much of the show, Emily and Lorelai frequently clashed, and their disagreements were rarely simple. Lorelai felt hurt by her parents because of her difficult upbringing – she had Rory as a teenager and left home before Rory turned one. However, much of this negativity seemed to come from Lorelai’s own feelings, leaving viewers unsure exactly why she held such strong resentment towards them.

It was clear that Lorelai’s mother was a perfectionist and very controlling, which made things difficult for Lorelai. However, the way Lorelai’s mother and grandmother treated Rory – almost excluding them from her life – felt unfair. You could understand both sides: Emily felt hurt that Lorelai kept Rory away, while Lorelai felt stifled by their attempts to control everything she and Rory did.

Okay, let’s talk about the Gilmore Girls episode ‘Wedding Bell Blues.’ This one really shifted things, finally letting us see Emily Gilmore through Lorelai’s eyes – all those criticisms Lorelai had been leveling for years suddenly made sense. The episode centers around Emily inviting Chris to her and Richard’s vow renewal, clearly hoping to rekindle Rory’s parents’ romance and, let’s be honest, sabotage Lorelai’s happiness. While you could argue Emily was trying to do what she thought was best for Lorelai, it was a seriously over-the-top move that even longtime fans had a hard time buying.

Everything goes according to plan when Chris, after having too much to drink, finally tells Lorelai how he feels – right in front of Luke. This leads to a fight between Lorelai and Luke, and then a heated argument between Luke and Chris about how Rory was raised, with Luke expressing that he’s always been a father figure to her. Feeling excluded from Lorelai’s family, Luke angrily leaves, and a devastated Lorelai completely cuts ties with her mother, Emily. While this episode gave viewers a deeper understanding of Lorelai’s past and made them fully sympathize with her, it came with a significant cost.

Wedding Bell Blues Destroyed Emily’s Character

By the fifth season, viewers were starting to appreciate Emily Gilmore, despite her sometimes overbearing personality. She was showing improvement in her relationships with Rory and Lorelai, accepting their choices and even adjusting Friday night dinners to be more accommodating. Small gestures, like making pudding for the girls, sharing a frozen pizza with Rory, and getting Rory a simple bracelet for her birthday, showed she was changing. She was becoming a truly beloved character on Gilmore Girls.

Emily Gilmore’s behavior surrounding Lorelai’s potential wedding was a significant step backward. Seeing Lorelai try on a dress triggered Emily to try and prevent her daughter from getting involved with Luke, whom she disapproved of. This controlling attempt echoed the reasons Lorelai initially left home, and it was arguably the most manipulative and intrusive Emily ever was.

Viewers always knew Emily didn’t approve of Luke – she wanted someone wealthy for her daughter, someone who could restore the family’s reputation. While she’d always voiced her disapproval, her recent actions – specifically, encouraging Chris to declare his feelings and disrupt Lorelai’s relationship – were seen as unforgivable.

Following the events of Wedding Bell Blues, Emily Gilmore underwent a significant shift. She went from being a complex, sympathetic mother figure to a clear villain. Her choices shattered the trust she’d been working to regain, turning her from a thoughtful person into someone driven by control and pride. This moment felt unforgivable to many viewers, and it remains a difficult episode for them to watch even after twenty years.

The Subsequent Episodes Didn’t Work in Emily’s Favor

To make things even more difficult, Emily doesn’t apologize for what she did. Instead, later episodes reveal she tries to defend her behavior and continues to keep secrets from Lorelai. For example, in the episode “So… Good Talk,” Emily and Richard come back from their second honeymoon right when they’re supposed to have Friday night dinner with Rory.

Rory is hurt by something her grandmother, Emily, did and spends most of the evening giving her the silent treatment. Emily gets angry in return, demanding to know why Rory is being so cold and taking Rory’s words personally. Instead of apologizing, Emily defends her actions, explaining she was only trying to help Lorelai and believing she could improve. This leads to a heated argument between Emily and Rory.

Later, hoping to fix things between Lorelai and Luke, Emily unexpectedly goes to Luke’s diner and asks him to get back together with Lorelai. The episode concludes with Luke going to see Lorelai and sharing a kiss on her porch, suggesting they’re finally on the path to resolving their issues. Despite this reconciliation, Emily still has some making up to do.

Okay, so in the next episode, “Pulp Friction,” I was totally surprised when Rory showed up to Friday night dinner by herself. Emily just assumed Luke and Lorelai were back on track after she talked to him, and immediately thought Luke was deliberately ignoring her wishes. She got so mad, she stormed over to Luke’s Diner and started yelling at him right in front of everyone! It got so bad, Luke had to call Lorelai to come and smooth things over. When Lorelai got there, she really laid into Emily, telling her to stop interfering and making it clear that Emily hadn’t helped anything – she’d actually made things worse!

This scene further damaged Emily’s reputation with viewers. She keeps blaming Luke, and only talks to him to try and control how Lorelai reacts. While Emily rarely admitted when she was wrong – something many understood given her background – this was a time she really should have taken responsibility. The storyline ultimately made it hard for the audience to feel any sympathy for her.

Emily Later Manipulated Lorelai Back into Her Life

Following her argument with Emily at the diner, Lorelai understandably stopped speaking to her mother. She began spending Friday nights with Luke, while Rory continued attending the weekly Gilmore family dinners alone—she felt obligated to, as Emily was helping to pay for Yale. However, things changed when someone new was invited to join them for dinner at the Gilmore house.

Lorelai, feeling uneasy about meeting her partner’s family, especially Mitchum Huntzberger, asks Emily if she can join them for dinner. Emily agrees, but only if Lorelai commits to attending every Friday night dinner going forward. Lorelai hesitantly accepts, and Emily is thrilled to have the weekly dinners resume.

The problem with the storyline was that it pushed Lorelai back into a relationship with Emily without ever dealing with their past issues. Emily never apologized, and their strained relationship remained unresolved. Lorelai was essentially guilt-tripped into attending Friday night dinners, which left many viewers feeling unsatisfied because Emily got her way without taking any responsibility for her actions.

Honestly, even as the show went on and Emily had a few small moments of growth, she never really made things right after what she did. It wasn’t just a quick apology – there was no real attempt to fix things. And because of that, every single scene between Emily and Lorelai after it felt… heavy. You could just feel the tension of that unresolved hurt hanging between them.

For a lot of viewers, the dinner between Logan and Lorelai felt like Emily intentionally exploited Lorelai’s emotional state to get her back under her control. This turned what could have been a genuine attempt at making amends into another example of Emily’s manipulation, and it’s still a particularly unsatisfying plot point for fans even today.

Read More

2025-11-19 21:39