This One Key Aliens Scene Has Been Turned Into a Lie by Romulus & Alien: Earth

by

The timeline of the Alien movies is incredibly confusing, and it doesn’t seem like it will be sorted out anytime soon. As the franchise continues with new films like Alien: Romulus and TV series like Alien: Earth, it’s getting harder to introduce new stories without contradicting what’s already been established in previous Alien films.

A prime example of this can be seen in James Cameron’s Aliens, which significantly shifted the direction of the story compared to Ridley Scott’s first film. Scott’s movie was a terrifying blend of science fiction and horror, while Cameron transformed it into a more action-packed, thrilling horror experience. Cameron aimed to build upon the world Scott created—not only the terrifying creatures (including their Queens and eggs), but also the powerful corporations responsible for the ill-fated mission of the Nostromo and its crew.

A key moment at the beginning of the film Aliens happens right after Ellen Ripley wakes up from a 60-year sleep in space. She’s questioned by representatives from Weyland-Yutani, the company she used to work for, and the meeting doesn’t go smoothly.

Aliens Established Xenomorphs As Total Unknowns

In a pivotal scene from Aliens, Ripley desperately tries to warn the Weyland-Yutani company about the deadly xenomorphs. However, the executives dismiss her claims, demanding proof she can’t provide. One of them points out that after surveying hundreds of planets, Weyland-Yutani has never encountered this creature before, questioning how something like Ripley describes could even exist. They essentially disbelieve everything she says about the creatures, remaining deeply skeptical.

Cameron’s film highlighted the dangers of unchecked capitalism and a future dominated by powerful corporations. The company, Weyland-Yutani, and its shifting attitude towards the xenomorphs, served as a symbol of how extreme greed could cause both environmental and biological catastrophes. Ultimately, Ripley argues that humans are a greater threat than the aliens themselves, because of their willingness to betray one another for financial gain.

Aliens Now Contradicts New Lore About Weyland-Yutani’s Xenomorph Project

Okay, so as a huge Alien fan, I’m starting to get really bothered by some continuity issues. That new Alien: Romulus movie kicks things off by showing Weyland-Yutani grabbing the Xenomorph from the wrecked Nostromo and using it to create this super-mutagen. That’s the whole reason the Romulus story happens, but it doesn’t really fit with what we know from Ripley’s report in Aliens. And now, the Alien: Earth series is making it even worse! They’ve revealed Weyland-Yutani had ships like the Maginot actively hunting alien creatures decades before the original Alien even happened, let alone before Aliens. It’s like they’re rewriting history and it’s messing with the timeline I’ve known and loved for years!

It seems unbelievable that Weyland-Yutani’s leaders didn’t know about the xenomorphs by the time Ripley was desperately warning them about the danger on LV-426. Even more puzzling, why would they intentionally establish a colony on a planet harboring such a deadly creature?

Like many inconsistencies in the Alien films, this scene in Aliens could be explained by details within the story itself. As seen in Alien: Earth and the movie Prometheus, the Weyland-Yutani corporation is made up of many different groups that don’t always work together. The Weyland and Yutani families seem to have their own goals, and different departments within the company, like science or weapons development, operate separately, meaning information isn’t always shared. Some fans have even created their own theories suggesting Ripley and the crew of the Nostromo were deliberately sent to LV-426 by a Weyland-Yutani executive who already knew about the xenomorphs and their potential worth.

To be honest, the Alien movies don’t need to be meticulously connected to make sense. The original film was meant to be a standalone story, and each sequel has largely followed its own vision. Alien 3 and Alien Resurrection are generally considered separate from the main storyline, and the Prometheus and Alien: Covenant prequels actually complicated things further. Even the newer films, like Romulus and the upcoming Earth, don’t perfectly align with any single Alien movie, but they at least try to connect to all of them in some way. It seems like a flexible timeline is the best we can expect from the franchise.

https://comicbook.com/movies/feature/after-35-years-predators-alien-connections-finally-matter/embed/#

Read More

2025-12-06 02:40