Probing Top Quark Interactions at the Future Circular Collider

Author: Denis Avetisyan


New analysis techniques promise precision measurements of rare top quark processes at the FCC-hh, offering a pathway to discover physics beyond the Standard Model.

Following event selection, the distribution of reconstructed <span class="katex-eq" data-katex-display="false"> t\overline{t}t\overline{t} </span> reveals the interplay between statistical and systematic uncertainties, which contribute uniquely to the overall precision of the measurement.
Following event selection, the distribution of reconstructed t\overline{t}t\overline{t} reveals the interplay between statistical and systematic uncertainties, which contribute uniquely to the overall precision of the measurement.

This review details the potential of differential $ar{t}tZ$ and $ar{t}tar{t}t$ measurements at large $Q^2$ to enhance sensitivity to new physics, requiring optimized lepton isolation and boosted regime analysis.

Precision measurements of top quark interactions are crucial for testing the Standard Model, yet current colliders limit sensitivity at high momentum transfer. This contribution, ‘Differential measurements of $\bar{t}tZ$ and $\bar{t}t\bar{t}t$ at large $Q^2$ at FCC-hh’, explores the potential of the Future Circular Collider to precisely measure the $\bar{t}tZ$ and $\bar{t}t\bar{t}t$ processes, demonstrating measurable transverse momentum spectra up to 2.5 TeV with competitive precision. Optimizations to lepton reconstruction, accounting for highly boosted objects, further enhance signal yields by up to a factor of 1.5. Will these advanced measurements at FCC-hh unlock new insights into physics beyond the Standard Model and reveal subtle deviations from current theoretical predictions?


Unveiling the Universe’s Hidden Layers: The Incompleteness of Current Models

Despite decades of experimental verification, the Standard Model of particle physics remains incomplete. While extraordinarily successful in describing the fundamental forces and particles observed thus far, it fails to account for phenomena such as dark matter, dark energy, and the observed mass of neutrinos. Furthermore, the model offers no explanation for the matter-antimatter asymmetry in the universe or the origin of the fundamental constants. These unresolved questions suggest the existence of physics beyond the Standard Model, prompting scientists to explore new theoretical frameworks and seek experimental evidence of previously unknown particles and interactions. The limitations of the current model drive the pursuit of higher-energy colliders, capable of probing energy scales where these new phenomena are expected to manifest, ultimately aiming to refine and expand humanity’s understanding of the universe’s most basic constituents.

The limitations of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) in fully exploring the universe’s most fundamental mysteries necessitate a significant leap in high-energy physics capabilities. While the LHC has been instrumental in confirming the Standard Model and discovering the Higgs boson, several crucial questions remain unanswered – from the nature of dark matter and dark energy to the origins of neutrino mass and the matter-antimatter asymmetry. Addressing these challenges demands probing energy scales beyond the LHC’s reach, effectively extending the ‘energy frontier’. This expansion allows physicists to create and observe even more massive particles and explore interactions at previously inaccessible levels, potentially revealing new physics beyond the Standard Model and reshaping our understanding of the cosmos. The current limitations aren’t merely technical; they represent a boundary on knowledge, and surpassing this boundary requires a collider capable of significantly higher energies and collision rates.

The Future Circular Collider (FCC-hh) represents a significant leap forward in particle physics, engineered to overcome the limitations of current accelerators like the LHC. Its design prioritizes both exceptionally high energy – enabling the exploration of previously unreachable physics – and unprecedented luminosity. This luminosity, projected at 30 ab⁻¹, signifies the total number of particle collisions within a given timeframe, and is roughly five times greater than that anticipated from the High-Luminescence LHC. Such an increase dramatically enhances the probability of observing rare processes and precisely measuring known ones, ultimately allowing physicists to meticulously map the properties of fundamental particles and search for evidence of new phenomena beyond the Standard Model with far greater statistical power.

Realizing the scientific promise of the Future Circular Collider – high-harmonic (FCC-hh) demands sophisticated computational techniques beyond current capabilities. The sheer volume of proton-proton collisions – aiming for an integrated luminosity of 30 ab-1 – will generate an immense dataset requiring innovative methods for event reconstruction. These reconstructions involve meticulously tracing the paths of particles created in collisions, identifying their properties, and ultimately discerning the underlying physics. Detailed simulations are crucial not only for optimizing the detector design to cope with this unprecedented collision rate, but also for developing algorithms capable of separating genuine signals – evidence of new physics – from the overwhelming background noise. Precise event reconstruction is therefore not merely a technical challenge, but a fundamental prerequisite for extracting meaningful discoveries from the FCC-hh and pushing the boundaries of particle physics.

Simulating the Cosmos: Modeling Top Quark Production

Precise modeling of top quark pair production (tt̄) is essential for the Future Circular Collider with hadron collisions (FCC-hh) due to the top quark’s significant mass and its role as a sensitive probe of new physics. Accurate simulation allows for the calibration of the FCC-hh detector components, specifically determining detector performance characteristics such as energy scale and resolution. Furthermore, tt̄ event samples serve as a benchmark for validating the Standard Model predictions and testing the accuracy of higher-order perturbative calculations, which are critical for interpreting experimental results and searching for deviations indicative of beyond-the-Standard-Model phenomena. The high luminosity of the FCC-hh necessitates robust and well-understood simulation tools to disentangle signal from background and accurately measure the properties of the top quark and other particles.

Monte Carlo event generators, such as MadGraph_aMCatNLO, are utilized to model the initial hard scattering process in high-energy physics simulations. These generators employ perturbative quantum chromodynamics (QCD) to calculate the probability of fundamental particle interactions, specifically the production of top quark pairs (tt̄). The calculations are performed to leading order (LO) or next-to-leading order (NLO) in the strong coupling constant, α_s, and involve integrating over the relevant phase space to determine the kinematic properties of the outgoing particles. MadGraph_aMCatNLO automates the calculation of these matrix elements and their subsequent integration, allowing for the generation of large samples of simulated events representing the initial state of a potential collision.

Pythia8 simulates the non-perturbative aspects of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) following the initial hard scattering process. Specifically, it models hadronization, the process by which quarks and gluons form composite particles like protons and neutrons, and parton showering, which describes the emission of additional quarks and gluons from the initial hard scattering partons. This involves evolving the partons down to lower energy scales using a probabilistic model based on established QCD evolution equations. The resulting particle showers accurately represent the complex final state produced in high-energy collisions, including the multitude of secondary particles generated from the fragmentation of the initial quarks and gluons, and are essential for linking the theoretical prediction to detector-level observables.

Delphes is a fast detector response simulation framework used to model the interaction of particles produced in high-energy collisions with a detector. It does not perform a full, detailed simulation of all detector components but instead parameterizes the detector performance through “cards” which define resolutions for energy measurement, efficiencies for particle identification, and the granularity of the detector elements. These cards allow users to quickly explore the impact of different detector designs and configurations on physics analyses. Delphes accounts for effects such as energy leakage between calorimeter cells, the probability of a particle being reconstructed, and the smearing of measured quantities like momentum and energy, providing a realistic, albeit simplified, representation of the detector response.

The <span class="katex-eq" data-katex-display="false">\text{p}_{T}(Z_{\ell\ell})</span> distribution for the <span class="katex-eq" data-katex-display="false">\text{t}\overline{\text{t}}Z</span> process demonstrates improved signal separation after applying isolation optimization, as shown by the reduced uncertainties in the bottom panels.
The \text{p}_{T}(Z_{\ell\ell}) distribution for the \text{t}\overline{\text{t}}Z process demonstrates improved signal separation after applying isolation optimization, as shown by the reduced uncertainties in the bottom panels.

Rare Glimpses into New Realities: Unveiling the Secrets of tt̄tt̄ Production

The production of four top quarks (tt̄tt̄) represents a rare interaction within the Standard Model. However, the Future Circular Collider with hadron collisions (FCC-hh) is projected to substantially increase the event rate due to its higher collision energy and luminosity. Specifically, the cross-section for tt̄tt̄ production at the FCC-hh is predicted to be 1.6 picobarns (pb). This represents a significant enhancement compared to the proton-proton collisions at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), where the observed cross-section is approximately 22.5 femtobarns (fb). The increased production rate at the FCC-hh will facilitate more detailed studies of this process and its sensitivity to physics beyond the Standard Model.

The study of four top quark (tt̄tt̄) production offers a sensitive avenue for probing physics beyond the Standard Model due to the process’s inherent dependence on the top quark self-coupling, \Gamma_{Htt} . This coupling, representing the strength of the interaction between a Higgs boson and two top quarks, is not precisely predicted within the Standard Model and can be modified by new physics. Precise measurements of the tt̄tt̄ cross-section and the kinematic distributions of the final state particles allow for constraints on anomalous \Gamma_{Htt} values, providing indirect evidence for new particles or interactions that affect the top quark sector. Deviations from Standard Model predictions in tt̄tt̄ event rates or distributions would therefore signal the presence of beyond-the-Standard-Model effects related to the top quark self-coupling.

The analysis of four top quark (tt̄tt̄) events necessitates the careful selection of final state particles due to the complexity of the decay products and the relatively low production cross-section. A common approach involves utilizing kinematic variables to enhance signal sensitivity and reduce background noise. The transverse momentum scalar sum (HT), calculated as the sum of the transverse momenta of all visible final state particles, is frequently employed as a key discriminant. Events with higher HT values generally correspond to more energetic collisions and are therefore more likely to represent genuine tt̄tt̄ signals. Optimization of HT selection cuts, alongside other kinematic variables, is crucial for maximizing the statistical significance of observed events and enabling precise measurements of the tt̄tt̄ production rate and associated parameters.

Accurate reconstruction of tt̄tt̄ events is heavily reliant on high-performance lepton identification. Optimized lepton isolation methods are critical for minimizing backgrounds and maximizing signal purity. Current techniques achieve electron identification efficiencies of 94% and muon identification efficiencies of 96%. These values represent substantial improvements over previously attainable levels, directly impacting the precision with which tt̄tt̄ signals can be isolated and studied at future colliders like the FCC-hh.

Beyond the Standard Model: Probing the Universe with tt̄Z Production

The simultaneous production of a top quark-antiquark pair and a Z boson – a process known as tt̄Z – presents a unique avenue for investigating the fundamental interactions of top quarks. While direct measurements of top quark couplings remain challenging, studying tt̄Z provides a complementary approach, allowing physicists to indirectly assess how these massive particles interact with the force-carrying bosons. This process is sensitive to subtle deviations from the Standard Model’s predictions, offering a crucial test of top quark properties and potentially revealing the influence of new, undiscovered particles or forces. By meticulously analyzing the characteristics of tt̄Z events, researchers can constrain the parameters governing top quark couplings with increasing precision, paving the way for a more complete understanding of the universe’s building blocks.

The transverse momentum of the lepton pair produced from Z boson decay, denoted as p_{T}(Zℓℓ), serves as a sensitive probe for physics beyond the Standard Model. Standard Model processes predict a characteristic distribution of this momentum, but new particles or interactions could subtly alter this pattern. By meticulously measuring p_{T}(Zℓℓ) in tt̄Z events, researchers can search for deviations from these predictions, potentially revealing the presence of new forces or particles influencing the interaction. These studies, particularly at future colliders, aim to achieve a precision of approximately 20% in the p_{T}(Zℓℓ) distribution, offering a powerful means of indirectly detecting new physics that may not be directly produced in collisions.

The meticulous measurement of both top quark-antiquark pair production alongside a Z boson (tt̄Z) and the rarer double top production (tt̄tt̄) offers a powerful avenue for scrutinizing the Standard Model. By comparing observed production rates with highly precise theoretical predictions generated within the framework of Effective Field Theory, physicists can search for subtle deviations indicative of new physics. These analyses project a remarkable level of sensitivity – a 35% precision in characterizing the distribution of transverse momentum (H_T) for tt̄tt̄ production at a center-of-mass energy of 3.5 TeV, and a 20% precision in the transverse momentum distribution of the leptons originating from the Z boson (p_{T}(Zℓℓ)) at 2.5 TeV – potentially revealing previously unknown interactions or particles beyond our current understanding of fundamental forces and matter.

Recent advancements in analyzing the transverse momentum of the Z boson’s decay leptons – achieved through optimized lepton isolation techniques – have dramatically sharpened the precision of p_{T}(Zℓℓ) distribution measurements, effectively doubling the accuracy in the highest momentum bins. This leap in analytical capability isn’t merely incremental; it positions the Future Circular Collider with hadron collisions (FCC-hh) as a leading experimental facility for probing the fundamental constituents of matter. These refined measurements offer an unprecedented opportunity to detect subtle deviations from the Standard Model, potentially revealing the existence of new particles or interactions and shedding light on long-standing mysteries within particle physics. The increased sensitivity promises to unravel the underlying nature of matter, going beyond the current limitations of our understanding.

The pursuit of precision in measurements, as detailed in this study of top quark interactions at the FCC-hh, echoes a fundamental principle of elegant design. Just as a well-crafted interface prioritizes clarity and minimizes unnecessary complexity, so too does this research refine techniques – like optimized lepton isolation – to extract meaningful signals from complex data. This careful distillation of information, focusing on the essential characteristics of particle interactions at large $Q^2$, aligns with the belief that form follows function. As Henry David Thoreau observed, “It is not enough to be busy; so are the ants. The question is: What are we busy with?” This work demonstrates a dedication to being busy with the pursuit of deeper understanding beyond the Standard Model, a pursuit made possible through rigorous methodology and a commitment to revealing the underlying harmony of the universe.

Beyond Precision: The Horizon for Top Quark Physics

The pursuit of precision in top quark measurements, as exemplified by this study of $\bar{t}tZ$ and $\bar{t}t\bar{t}t$ interactions at the FCC-hh, inevitably reveals not triumph, but the exquisite detail of one’s ignorance. To map differential cross sections at large $Q^2$ is to chart the coastline of the Standard Model, and to discover where the land gives way to the ocean of the unknown. The sensitivity gains projected here are not merely about confirming known physics with greater accuracy; they are an invitation to find where the elegant structure falters.

The challenges are not solely experimental. Refined lepton isolation techniques, crucial for disentangling signals, represent a necessary but insufficient condition. A truly revealing analysis demands a parallel evolution in theoretical understanding-a move beyond simply parameterizing deviations, towards genuinely predictive frameworks. Effective field theory, while useful, can become a baroque exercise in fitting; the goal is not to describe what deviates, but to understand why.

The future of this field hinges on embracing complexity, not by adding layers of ad-hoc corrections, but by seeking deeper, more unified principles. The structure of the top quark sector, its couplings, and its role in electroweak symmetry breaking-these are not isolated problems. They are facets of a larger, more beautiful puzzle. The exquisite precision offered by the FCC-hh is a tool, but true progress demands a willingness to abandon comfortable assumptions and to follow the evidence, however unsettling, towards a more complete, and ultimately, more elegant description of reality.


Original article: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.04763.pdf

Contact the author: https://www.linkedin.com/in/avetisyan/

See also:

2026-01-10 12:26