Watchmen’s Hooded Justice Retcon Made a Forgotten Backstory Iconic

by

As a huge comic book fan, I remember when Watchmen came out – it was a total game-changer. Along with a few other series at the time, it really proved that comics could be serious art. It’s funny though, because the creator, Alan Moore, is incredibly protective of his work. He’s famously turned down everyone who’s ever tried to make a sequel or even just build on the Watchmen story – he wants it left exactly as he created it!

HBO’s series actually proves Alan Moore wrong about his own creation. The show cleverly expanded on a minor detail from the original graphic novel, dramatically changing the character of Hooded Justice. Instead of being a German sympathizer as originally depicted, the series reveals him to be a Black man battling a sinister plot, and his anger is shown to be the driving force behind everything. This retcon, led by Lost co-creator Damon Lindelof, serves as a powerful sequel to the comic book series.

Moore and Gibbons’ Watchmen Legitimized Comics With a Deeply Cynical Take on the Genre

When comics moved from the Silver Age to the Bronze Age, a creative revival helped slow down a period of falling sales. DC Comics bought the rights to a struggling competitor. One writer, known for a complex, psychological take on superheroes, initially planned a story using existing characters, but DC had other ideas. He and his artist ended up creating new characters, which proved to be a better fit for the story they wanted to tell. Despite these changes, one of the costumed heroes remained largely enigmatic.

Most of the story in Watchmen happens after superheroes were outlawed because their actions caused too many problems. Everyone knew the real identities of these heroes, except for the very first one to wear a mask.

Hooded Justice first appeared in 1938—the same year Superman was introduced in comic books, which wasn’t a coincidence. His costume included an executioner’s hood and a noose, creating a striking and unsettling image.

Alan Moore’s Watchmen famously ended with a devastating attack on a city by a colossal, sea creature-like alien. The comic challenged the idea that superheroes were inherently good, proving to many that such stories could be complex and even cynical. Watchmen ultimately presented a more nuanced take on superheroes, contrasting them with ancient myths where gods often behaved just as badly as the villains.

Hooded Justice was a complex character with a hidden life. He was a gay man who bravely intervened when the Comedian attacked Silk Spectre, but he also held prejudiced views and even expressed support for Hitler and the Nazis. The story suggests he might have been Rolf Müller, a German strongman who mysteriously died.

HBO’s Watchmen Series Is a Worthy Successor and Its Hooded Justice Retcon Shows Why

What’s really striking about this show is how the police operate now – they’re masked, anonymous, and seem to have no accountability. It’s a wild setup, and the show cleverly uses a style that reminds me of Ryan Murphy’s work on shows like those on FX to show us how the people in this world perceive the characters we first met in the original graphic novel. It’s like seeing those familiar faces through a distorted, satirical lens.

American Hero Story retells the story familiar to readers of the graphic novel. This approach subtly prepares viewers, making the reveal of Hooded Justice’s origins genuinely surprising. The reveal cleverly mirrors current events involving costumed police and ultimately enhances the impact of Moore’s original narrative.

This change to the story’s background provided a reason for the officer to wear a mask. The idea was, what if he were a Black man in the 1940s, forced to conceal his identity because society wouldn’t accept a Black superhero? Will Reeves, a survivor of the 1921 Tulsa Massacre, nearly faced a lynching by his own police colleagues while investigating a racist group known as Cyclops.

Okay, so the premise is intense. We’re introduced to this guy absolutely broken by past trauma – still haunted, literally weighed down by the symbols of it. He’s walking through the city when he stumbles upon a brutal attack. And in that moment, something snaps. He rips holes in the hood that’s been suffocating him – a hood placed there by those who wronged him – and unleashes a furious, masked vigilante. It’s a really striking visual metaphor, and honestly, a pretty powerful origin story. He becomes something else, something driven by rage and a need to protect, and that something is Hooded Justice. It’s dark, it’s visceral, and it immediately grabs your attention.

The villain Cyclops, with his outlandish plan for racist mind control, feels like a silly comic book idea brought to life with the same unsettling effect as the characters in the graphic novel Watchmen. The reason Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons deliberately left the Hooded Justice’s true identity a mystery remains unclear, though it might have been a deliberate irony, considering how well-known Superman’s origins are.

Unlike stories where heroes are selfless and dedicated to helping others, this universe is built on conflict, anger, and trickery. This makes everything that happens in the graphic novel feel more realistic and justified.

Making Will Reeves the Precursor to the Original Watchmen Changes It for the Better

As a huge fan of the original ‘Watchmen,’ I really appreciated how the HBO series didn’t tie everything up neatly. Some people, including Alan Moore himself and some of his fans, might disagree, but to me, the show felt like a loving tribute. It wasn’t about changing the source material, but expanding on it. You can see it in things like how Rorschach’s ideas sparked the return of the Cyclops group, and even in what happened with Doctor Manhattan – the series clearly aimed to build upon and deepen the story we already knew and loved.

Ultimately, new installments can’t alter how someone initially feels about a story. People who prefer the original are entitled to their opinion, even if others disagree. However, the character of Will Reeves as Hooded Justice enriches the original narrative and reinforces its core themes.

The flashbacks featuring Nelson Gardner, also known as Captain Metropolis, show Will as a genuinely committed hero facing a real supervillain problem. But Gardner seems to be just pretending, and villains like Moloch are aware it’s all a joke. The Crimebusters and, eventually, the Minutemen, remain as troubled and flawed as Alan Moore originally portrayed them.

Unlike Reeves’s focused goal, these individuals are acting out a fantasy with dangerous consequences, using real weapons and harming innocent people. Their actions stem from anger and a desire to punish those they believe deserve it, resulting in violence and destruction.

It’s somewhat ironic, mirroring Alan Moore’s approach with his comics. However, unlike the famously difficult Moore, Lindelof actively encouraged other talented writers to continue the story. The idea of rewriting established history – a common comic book device – was something Moore and Gibbons couldn’t fully explore without a follow-up, and the HBO series brilliantly utilized this technique.

Rather than feeling like a minor addition, the show integrated Hooded Justice and his backstory into the core themes of the graphic novel. While more stories set in this world won’t diminish the original Watchmen, the HBO series demonstrates how they could actually enhance it.

Read More

2026-02-17 03:38