7 Divisive Anime Characters That Split the Fandom

by

Well-developed characters are often a strength in anime, but sometimes they create strong disagreements among fans. This can actually be a sign of good writing, as believable, complex characters naturally evoke powerful reactions. However, if a character isn’t developed effectively, it can frustrate viewers. Some fans will then criticize the character themselves, while others will focus on the writing as the source of the problem.

Characters who spark a lot of debate often become the most well-known. Even if they’re controversial or disliked by some, constant discussion keeps them in the spotlight. Whether it’s a hero who becomes a villain or someone who makes a bad first impression, these figures consistently divide fans.

7) Eren Yeager

Attack on Titan

Eren Yeager is a very controversial character in the anime world, and it’s easy to understand why. Attack on Titan initially presents him as the hero, but then shockingly reveals him to be the villain. He does terrible things, becoming as destructive as the enemies he’s fighting, all in the name of protecting his people. Despite these wrongdoings, many fans still sympathize with him, which shows how well-developed and relatable he is throughout the series. Attack on Titan masterfully portrays a character’s descent into darkness while still making the audience understand their motivations.

6) Katsuki Bakugo

My Hero Academia

Bakugo’s journey towards becoming a better person is considered one of the best in anime, but not everyone agrees. He remains a controversial character among fans of My Hero Academia, even though he’s actively trying to make amends for his past actions and improve himself. His early bullying of Deku left a negative impression on some viewers, which is hard for them to forget. Even after changing, Bakugo can still be harsh, but many are now more sympathetic towards him. He was young when he acted poorly, and he’s genuinely working to own up to his mistakes and grow. While Bakugo often ranks high in popularity polls, he also frequently receives criticism.

5) Light Yagami

Death Note

Although Light Yagami is the central character in Death Note, he’s far from a traditional hero. Despite believing he’s justified in his actions, he’s essentially a killer. What makes Light so captivating is that he genuinely seems to believe in his cause, which is likely why he remains popular with fans. He demonstrates that complex, morally gray characters are often the most interesting, and many viewers find themselves supporting him despite his flaws. Of course, many others disagree and side with L instead. Like Eren, Light is a brilliantly written character who sparks debate and divides the audience.

4) Sakura Haruno

Naruto

Fans of Naruto generally adore the main character, Naruto, and dislike Sasuke, but opinions on Sakura are more divided. Sakura’s portrayal often suffers from the show’s writing. While she’s not a bad character – and has some strong moments at the beginning – she doesn’t get the same chances to develop as Naruto and Sasuke. Compared to them, her storyline often feels less engaging, largely focusing on her romantic feelings for Sasuke. This leads to a lot of criticism, although Sakura does have her dedicated supporters.

3) Subaru Natsuki

Re:Zero – Starting Life in Another World

Subaru Natsuki, the main character in Re:Zero – Starting Life in Another World, is very flawed, which makes him feel real – but also divides viewers. While criticism isn’t as harsh as it is for characters like Eren or Light, many people still have issues with him. Some find him too clumsy and childish to root for, while others appreciate his very human qualities. He does develop as a character throughout the anime, but some viewers struggle to move past his initial awkwardness.

2) Griffith

Berserk

Griffith from Berserk is a remarkably complex character, and he often sparks debate among anime fans. He starts as a seemingly noble leader, but a significant betrayal transforms him into a villain. This act is central to who he is, but opinions on it vary widely. Some viewers try to find understanding for his actions, despite him not attempting to make amends, while others see him as completely unforgivable – a view that’s hard to dispute.

1) Gabi Braun

Attack on Titan

Eren isn’t the only character in Attack on Titan that fans have strong, differing opinions about—Gabi often divides viewers just as much. It’s understandable why many initially dislike her; she starts out supporting harmful ideas and, crucially, she’s responsible for the death of Sasha, a fan favorite. While Gabi eventually recognizes her mistakes, some viewers feel her change of heart comes too late to redeem her. Others view her as a deliberately complex character, acknowledging the nuances of her journey.

What anime character gives you mixed feelings? Share your thoughts in the comments below and discuss it with other fans in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/anime/news/best-anime-characters-outshine-main-protagonist-itachi-levi/embed/#

Read More

2026-02-24 03:12