Despite being canceled after just one season, Star Trek: The Next Generation unexpectedly became a major franchise. However, the show’s passionate fans made a significant error by unfairly targeting one character: Wesley Crusher. Even now, almost forty years later, the actor Wil Wheaton, who played the bright and gifted young Starfleet officer, deserves more appreciation for his portrayal.
It’s a bit of an irony that some of the harshest critics of Star Trek are its biggest fans. This tendency to find fault isn’t unique – you see it with franchises like Star Wars and the Marvel Cinematic Universe, too – but Star Trek fans have a particularly long history of it. In fact, when fans protested to get more episodes made, the network responded with a sequel… an animated series. While newer Star Trek shows continue this pattern, they often downplay the negativity that beloved series like The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, and Voyager faced. The dislike for the character Wesley Crusher, for example, became a widespread joke online. But both the character and the actor who played him were unfairly targeted, and the reasons given by the haters don’t really stand up to close examination.
As TNG Struggled In Early Seasons, Wesley Crusher’s Character Suffered the Most
Back in the 1980s, most people in Hollywood believed that TV show sequels were never as good as the original. While Star Trek: The Original Series found an audience through reruns, it wasn’t a huge success when it first aired. However, the dedicated fans – known as Trekkies – convinced Paramount to bring the show back in the 1970s, eventually leading to the popular movie franchise.
Following the success of Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home, Paramount asked Gene Roddenberry to create The Next Generation. While the new USS Enterprise had a fresh and interesting crew, one character stood out: Wesley Crusher. Roddenberry based Wesley on his own teenage self, imagining what he would have been like at 14 if he’d been a genius.
Many of the ideas originally planned for Star Trek: Phase II ended up in the first movie featuring the original cast. When it was time to create the sequel series, The Next Generation, Roddenberry and the original TOS producers – like Bob Justman, Dorothy Fontana, and David Gerrold – aimed for a significantly different approach. However, Roddenberry, known for being resourceful, still incorporated many of those earlier concepts into the new show.
It appears Wesley Crusher was a recognizable character for many fans and fanfiction writers of Star Trek at the time. Originally, the show’s creator, Justman, considered making the character a young woman, as teenage experiences weren’t often shown on television. They even held auditions for an actress to play “Leslie Crusher,” a 15-year-old girl with a similar personality, but ultimately decided to keep the character as a young man.
The term “Mary Sue,” often misused in fan criticism, actually originated with Star Trek fan and writer Paula Smith in the world of fanfiction. In some ways, Wesley Crusher embodies this trope – he’s a character who’s almost a creator’s self-insert. However, unlike typical “Mary Sue” characters, the people around him don’t instantly love him. And despite frequently saving the ship and its crew, Wesley isn’t portrayed as flawless.
While often celebrated for his successes, Wesley Crusher frequently gains important insights from his fellow crew members. He later reappeared in two episodes after leaving the main cast, during which he broke Starfleet regulations and contributed to an incident that resulted in the death of a classmate.
Wesley Crusher Was Controversial Among Star Trek: TNG Fans For a Few Reasons
Many of the initial criticisms of Wesley Crusher’s storylines stemmed from a simple dislike of his character. Some dedicated Star Trek fans felt it wasn’t right for a teenage cadet to be stationed on the bridge of the Enterprise, and this has been a frequent topic of debate among fans online.
Viewers also had trouble accepting that Wesley consistently saved the day in each episode. However, for shows like Star Trek – where unbelievable events are common – criticisms of a story’s realism usually come down to personal preference. The reaction to Wesley Crusher was similar to…
The reaction to Wesley Crusher became surprisingly harsh, mainly because the young fans he interacted with hadn’t yet experienced the show’s technology. Similar to how many fans fondly remember Jar Jar Binks from the prequel films, viewers who grew up with The Next Generation connected with Wesley. He represented the potential for heroism and gained the admiration of accomplished adult characters, making him a significant figure for many young viewers.
Seeing yourself reflected in media is important, and Wesley Crusher helped many young viewers connect with the world of Star Trek. However, the show’s writing sometimes made things difficult. The writers, particularly in the early seasons, struggled to create stories that were consistently interesting, meaningful, and fun.
Sadly, the show never quite made Wesley feel like a typical kid his age. One episode showed him playing ball with aliens as if he were in grade school, but attempts to give him romantic storylines also didn’t connect with viewers of any age.
Wil Wheaton Had Good Reason to Leave TNG, Which Completely Changed the Show
When Star Trek: The Next Generation first aired in 1987, Wil Wheaton was probably the most well-known actor in the show. This was mainly because of his memorable role in the film Stand by Me, which had already connected with a large audience, while Patrick Stewart, though a respected stage actor, hadn’t yet achieved that same level of widespread recognition.
Honestly, when Wesley Crusher left the Enterprise, even people who weren’t his biggest fans were surprised. The explanation they gave – he was going to Starfleet Academy to complete his education – didn’t quite sit right. He was already so smart and had learned so much on the ship, it felt like a backwards move. We eventually found out the real reason, and it made a lot more sense.
Patrick Stewart couldn’t take a week off from filming Star Trek: The Next Generation to complete a movie he’d started during the show’s break. The producers had insisted the episode was crucial for his character, Wesley Crusher, his connection with his mother, Dr. Beverly Crusher, and the show’s storyline as a whole. However, when it was time to film, the planned story arc for Wesley had been completely dropped.
In Edward Gross and Mark A. Altman’s book, The Fifty-Year Mission – The Next 25 Years, Wil Wheaton shared that Star Trek producers worried accepting a film role from Milos Forman would have made him a movie star, and therefore more difficult to work with.
Wil Wheaton left the show due to negative experiences with the producers, but the harsh treatment he received from fans for playing Wesley Crusher also contributed to his decision. Though he left, Wesley Crusher reappeared in a few episodes, including those in the final season. What’s especially touching is…
Compared to the original Star Trek cast, the actors from The Next Generation had a much friendlier and more supportive dynamic. They’ve remained genuinely close even after the show finished, and that positive experience probably explains why Wesley Crusher made a return appearance.
Wesley Crusher’s TNG Ending Was Great But His Star Trek Return Was Even Better
When Star Trek came back for a new set of shows, Wil Wheaton hosted an online series called The Ready Room. This show broke down each episode and included interviews with the actors and crew. It wasn’t until the second season of Star Trek: Picard that…
Even though a scene was cut from the poorly received movie Nemesis, this moment proved he was still a “Traveler.” In his final TNG episode, Crusher once again left the Enterprise to work with a mysterious organization that safeguarded time and reality.
Wesley Crusher made a significant comeback in Season 2 of Star Trek: Prodigy, finally showcasing the full scope of his skills. Similar to what happened with Jar Jar Binks, many of the original fans of Wesley grew up and helped to shift the conversation around the character. Plus, people began to recognize that it’s simply wrong to bully a teenager over a role they played.
I was so thrilled to see Wesley Crusher back in Prodigy! He really came into his own, becoming a strong leader and a key part of the whole adventure. Honestly, it felt like a chance to give a great character even more depth, even though he was already so well-loved. The show also introduced us to his brother, Jack, which was a fantastic surprise. And it was amazing – unlike his time on TNG, fans were genuinely excited to see Wesley return. It felt like a true celebration of the character.
The reaction to Wesley Crusher is puzzling. While the criticism of the actor is valid, a fair look back at Star Trek: The Next Generation reveals that the character didn’t deserve the negativity. His storylines had problems, but not any more than other minor flaws found throughout the series. It’s unfortunate this became a lasting issue for a show that champions acceptance, kindness, and compassion.
Found an error? Send it so it can be corrected.
Read More
- Epic Games Store Giving Away $45 Worth of PC Games for Free
- When Is Hoppers’ Digital & Streaming Release Date?
- Sunday Rose Kidman Urban Describes Mom Nicole Kidman In Rare Interview
- 40 Inspiring Optimus Prime Quotes
- 10 Movies That Were Secretly Sequels
- Best Werewolf Movies (October 2025)
- 7 Best Animated Horror TV Shows
- There’s Blood In The Water In Thrash First Footage – Watch The Trailer
- 32 Kids Movies From The ’90s I Still Like Despite Being Kind Of Terrible
- 10 Great Netflix Dramas That Nobody Talks About
2026-03-13 07:10