Dark Souls Should Never Be Remade for One Simple Reason

by

The original Dark Souls is highly praised by action RPG players, and for good reason. It really put FromSoftware on the map, popularizing their unique approach to exploring detailed worlds, challenging gameplay, and immersive fantasy settings. The game features a beautifully connected world and demanding combat that requires players to truly master its systems, making it feel special even today. As Dark Souls approaches its 15th anniversary in 2026, it’s clear that its overall experience remains one of a kind.

The development of the Dark Souls series is clear when looking at games like Dark Souls 3, Bloodborne, and Elden Ring, which all show how the games have grown from their original design. Despite these newer games becoming more focused on action or offering open worlds, Dark Souls still feels distinct. This difference mainly comes down to its gameplay mechanics; Dark Souls has specific limitations that make it a uniquely challenging experience.

The Original Dark Souls’ Combat & Gameplay Is Timeless Despite Its Age

Man, seeing how amazing the Demon’s Souls remake is on PS5 makes me wonder why we haven’t gotten the same treatment for the original Dark Souls. Yeah, Dark Souls: Remastered fixed a bunch of bugs, but it wasn’t a huge overhaul. Honestly though, I don’t even think a full remake is a good idea. The original Dark Souls is so iconic because of how all its systems work together, and I’m worried a remake would mess with that core identity. It’s perfect as is, really.

The combat in the original Dark Souls feels much more restrictive and less fluid than in later games like Dark Souls 3 or Elden Ring, and that’s by design. It requires players to be extremely precise with every move – timing attacks, spells, and even simple actions is crucial. This deliberate limitation creates a challenging experience where mistakes are heavily penalized. A good example is healing: when you use a healing flask, your character has to pause and finish the animation, leaving them vulnerable and unable to dodge.

This animation makes you very open to enemy attacks. Because of this, you need to carefully choose when to heal, and manage your stamina so you can run or roll to safety before drinking a potion. This careful timing is a key part of combat in Dark Souls. You’ll also need to learn how the environment and enemy actions work, as they each have their own specific rules. This challenging design extends to other game elements, like Poise and limited uses for certain spells.

Like later games, Dark Souls features character stats and weight limits, but these are more restrictive and difficult to manage. The original Dark Souls is very precise and unforgiving, with clearly defined mechanics and few ways to exploit the system. Everything your character does – from swinging a sword to using an item or casting a spell – feels weighty and impactful. While this interconnectedness can be challenging, many players find it creates a unique experience compared to most modern action RPGs.

Remastering Dark Souls To Be More Like Dark Souls 3 Or Elden Ring Would Be A Misstep

Updating Dark Souls with modern graphics would dramatically improve how the game looks, making its memorable bosses, environments, and special effects much more impressive. However, this could also unintentionally change key aspects of the original gameplay. A remake or even a detailed remaster might remove some of the challenging limitations that made Dark Souls stand out from other difficult action games.

I absolutely love how fluid the combat is in games like Elden Ring and Dark Souls 3, but honestly, I think bringing those same systems to the original Dark Souls would actually hurt the experience. Like, if dodges had more invincibility frames, a famously tough boss fight like Ornstein and Smough would become way easier, and it wouldn’t feel as rewarding. It’s the same with things like being able to move while healing with Estus, or if status effects weren’t as punishing. Those limitations are part of what made the original Dark Souls so special and challenging, and removing them would just make it feel…less good, you know?

I don’t think a remaster or remake can truly capture the spirit of the original Dark Souls. While some improvements might seem good, changing too much of the game risks losing what makes it special. Ultimately, that’s what solidifies its status as a masterpiece – it might be best left untouched.

Would you like to see a complete overhaul of Dark Souls, like a remaster or remake? Share your opinion in the comments or discuss it with other fans on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/gaming/news/fromsoftware-soulslike-games-best-worst-dark-souls-elden-ring/embed/#

Read More

2026-03-15 17:16