5 Anime That Peaked With Season 1 (#1 Is So Frustrating)

by

Ideally, each new season of an anime would be better than the last. However, some shows that start strong don’t manage to maintain that quality beyond their first season. A good beginning is important, but a series needs to build on that foundation and deliver on its initial promises. While some anime consistently improve, others reach their peak early and don’t quite live up to their potential.

Sometimes, when an anime tries something new, not living up to initial hopes can actually be a positive thing. But usually, it means the show is starting to decline, and it’s hard to recover. For anime like The Promised Neverland, it results in a disappointing ending. In other cases, viewers become frustrated and lower their expectations for the series.

5) The Promised Neverland

Season 1 of The Promised Neverland is a fantastic start to the series. It quickly makes you care about the characters and puts them in a terrifying and dangerous situation. The first episode ends with a shocking twist: the orphans at Grace Field House are being raised as food. This is just the beginning of a much darker and more intense story.

The first chapter immediately grabs your attention as Emma and her friends try to avoid their predetermined destinies. Reaching the outside world seemed full of potential, but Season 2 unfortunately doesn’t live up to that promise. It surprisingly changes the story from the original manga, even removing a popular story arc. The new storyline created for the anime doesn’t add much to the first season and leaves the show feeling unsatisfying.

4) Tokyo Ghoul

Like many anime adaptations, Tokyo Ghoul suffers when it moves away from its original manga source. This is especially noticeable with Season 2, which is generally considered much weaker than the first. The initial season effectively introduces Ken Kaneki’s story, showing his transformation into a half-ghoul and his fight to maintain his humanity. The season ends on a compelling note, leaving viewers curious about his future. Unfortunately, Season 2, specifically the Root A arc, abandons the manga’s storyline and instead presents an entirely new, anime-exclusive plot, failing to build on the promising setup.

It’s no surprise that many dedicated fans disliked the changes made to the story. While Season 3 of Tokyo Ghoul tried to fix things by going back to the original manga plot, it wasn’t able to win back viewers. It’s a pity, because the first season showed a lot of promise with its dark and interesting storyline, despite some flaws. Overall, Tokyo Ghoul is a story that’s probably best enjoyed in manga form.

3) Psycho-Pass

The first season of Psycho-Pass effectively launches the anime with a compelling dystopian setting: a future Japan where technology assesses people’s mental states to predict criminal behavior. This leads to potentially problematic preventative measures, and creates opportunities for individuals who can manipulate the system. The main characters of Psycho-Pass must then hunt down a criminal who’s managed to do just that. Season 1 explores this concept with intelligence and depth, fully realizing the potential of its dark, futuristic world.

While Seasons 2 and 3 of Psycho-Pass aren’t poor continuations of the story, they don’t quite live up to the quality of the first season. The original season was exceptionally well-written and plotted, setting a standard the later seasons struggle to reach. The show’s insightful themes remain strong, but other elements aren’t as compelling, and the villains aren’t particularly memorable.

2) The Seven Deadly Sins

Netflix has some great anime, and the first season of The Seven Deadly Sins is definitely a good place to start. However, the show gets weaker in later seasons. The series begins strongly, with interesting characters, good animation and exciting action. Season 2 is still decent, but the first season remains the best. After that, the quality drops, and many fans might prefer to read the original manga instead.

I’ve noticed a lot of fans feel the animation in the later parts of The Seven Deadly Sins really lets things down. Some of the fights that should have been super exciting just didn’t quite hit the mark because of it. Honestly, the story didn’t really build on what made the first season so good, and it feels like the show was at its best right from the beginning.

1) One-Punch Man

Despite a fantastic first season, One-Punch Man is a bit of a disappointment. The initial episodes perfectly captured the spirit of the original manga and had all the potential to become a major hit. It skillfully blended exciting action with humor and charm, and the animation was top-notch. However, the second season doesn’t live up to the same standard, even though the storyline continues to follow the interesting path of the manga.

Season 3 of One-Punch Man feels like the final blow for the series, unfortunately, as the quality continues to drop – especially after fans waited six years for new episodes. While the season is still being released, the gaps between parts might frustrate viewers even more. This is particularly disheartening given how excellent the original manga is. The fantastic anime adaptation of ONE’s other work, Mob Psycho 100, proves what One-Punch Man could achieve with a little more dedication.

What anime series do you think was best during its first season? Share your thoughts in the comments and join the discussion on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/anime/list/7-greatest-shonen-anime-protagonists-who-arent-from-the-big-3/embed/#

Read More

2026-03-16 02:13