Nearly 30 Years Later, Is This Still the Worst Superhero Video Game?

by

Superheroes have always inspired video game creators with their exciting powers, memorable characters, and action-packed stories. This has led to some fantastic games, like X-Men, Spider-Man 2, and Batman: Arkham City, which really defined their time. However, not all superhero games are winners – many haven’t lived up to expectations or felt poorly made.

As a long-time gamer, I still remember the buzz around Superman 64 when it came out for the N64 almost thirty years ago! Everyone was excited about the idea of flying around a fully open Metropolis, but sadly, the game ended up being notoriously difficult to control and just… not very good. It became famous as one of the biggest critical failures in gaming history, even though it surprisingly sold okay. Now, looking back, it’s fascinating to revisit the game and try to understand what went wrong – and whether it truly deserves the title of ‘worst superhero game ever’.

Superman: The New Superman Adventures Was Kryptonite To Game Critics

Released for the Nintendo 64 on May 24, 1999, Superman: The New Superman Adventures aimed to bring the excitement of Superman’s adventures to home consoles. Though connected to Superman: The Animated Series, the game tells the story of Superman being trapped in a virtual reality created by Lex Luthor and Brainiac, where he must battle his greatest foes to rescue his friends and family. Developed by Titus Interactive, the game quickly gained a reputation for being a poor adaptation of the superhero. Gameplay mainly involved flying through virtual environments, navigating mazes designed by Luthor, rescuing citizens, and quick, limited combat encounters.

The game’s world feels empty and uninteresting because it’s mostly a visual backdrop. This is a significant departure from the developers’ initial vision of a bustling, open-world superhero adventure. The game was limited by the console’s technology, meaning much of what they planned couldn’t be included. A tight deadline, driven by the desire to release the game alongside the unreleased film Superman Lives, added intense pressure. Furthermore, changes within Warner Bros. created conflict between the development team and the company, making the development process even more difficult.

Oh man, Superman 64. I remember being so hyped for it back then, but it was…rough. Honestly, the gameplay felt really clunky, and it just didn’t look good, even for the time. Plus, it was full of bugs, which made everything even worse. Everyone slammed it – it got terrible scores, and a lot of people consider it one of the worst superhero games ever made. It actually sold okay initially, but between the huge marketing costs and having to pay for the Superman license, it didn’t make much money in the end. Basically, it was a flop, and it’s only become more infamous over the years. It’s a shame, because I really wanted to love it!

What Is The Worst Superhero Game Ever?

Superhero video games have always been hit or miss. Even in the early days of arcades, while games like Konami’s X-Men were great, others, like Batman: Return of the Joker, felt like odd departures from the source material – more like a Ninja Gaiden game with Batman’s name on it. There were plenty of disappointing superhero games even before Superman 64 came out. Titles like the 1995 Batman Forever and 1997’s Fantastic Four were clunky and awkward side-scrollers that just weren’t very fun. And unfortunately, more recent games, such as the 2004 Catwoman and 2011’s X-Men: Destiny, haven’t fared much better with critics.

Okay, so everyone talks about how awful Superman 64 is, but it’s honestly not alone! As a gamer, I was surprised to learn there are actually a few other superhero games that critics scored just as poorly, or even worse. Superman: The New Superman Adventures got a 30/100 on MetaCritic. Then there’s Batman: Dark Tomorrow and Aquaman: Battle for Atlantis, both from 2003. They were pretty rough – clunky controls, boring fights, and lots of glitches. Batman managed a 29/100 thanks to a slightly better story, but Aquaman only hit 26/100. And if you go back to 2000, Batman Beyond: The Return of the Joker on the N64 was even worse, scoring a measly 24/100. Critics really slammed it for its bad design, terrible graphics, and just… boring gameplay. So yeah, Superman 64 isn’t the only superhero game that missed the mark!

Despite many attempts, no superhero game frustrated players quite like Superman 64. Perhaps its widespread release meant more people experienced its disappointing take on the iconic character. Or maybe the empty city and repetitive gameplay perfectly symbolized the struggles of early 3D game design. Of course, enjoyment is subjective – some younger players actually liked Superman 64, and many modern superhero games also have their flaws. However, in the public consciousness, it remains the benchmark for bad superhero games, even if a few others are arguably even worse.

Read More

2026-05-29 20:11