Carnival of Souls Is 1 of the Creepiest Ghost Stories Ever Made

by

Fans of David Lynch appreciate films that create a sense of dread, unease, and disorientation – qualities that make a horror movie truly terrifying. Given Lynch’s enduring influence and with Halloween approaching, it’s a perfect time to talk about *Carnival of Souls*. This low-budget, black-and-white film from 1962, made without any well-known stars, uses eerie sounds and a consistently unsettling mood to feel otherworldly and strangely captivating.

Created with a remarkably small budget of around $33,000, this film tells a haunting and unusual story about a woman who barely survives a car accident and then feels lost in a world that doesn’t seem to acknowledge her. Though it initially failed at the box office, the movie was rediscovered decades later through late-night television, eventually gaining a dedicated and devoted cult following. *Carnival of Souls* became a hugely influential independent horror film, and its surreal style and eerie atmosphere directly inspired iconic directors like David Lynch and George A. Romero.

Carnival of Souls Is a Ghost Story That Feels Like a Dream

The film *Carnival of Souls* opens and closes with a striking scene. It centers around Mary Henry, who survives a car accident after her vehicle goes off a bridge into a river. Though the police assume the worst, she unexpectedly appears hours later, seemingly unharmed. She attempts to rebuild her life by relocating and becoming a church organist, but soon realizes something unsettling is happening to her.

After the event, Mary feels increasingly detached from everything and everyone around her. Conversations feel empty, and she’s plagued by disturbing visions of a ghostly man and a deserted carnival on the edge of town. While the story’s setup clearly signals a creepy atmosphere, the film’s true horror lies in what isn’t said – the moments of silence are the most terrifying.

Director Herk Harvey wanted his film to have the visual style of classic European art films, specifically evoking the atmosphere of filmmakers like Bergman and Cocteau. He achieved this by minimizing explanations and dialogue, and instead using extended, disturbing silences and dreamlike imagery. The film’s unsettling organ music, composed by Gene Moore, enhances this effect, creating a soundscape that feels like it reflects the character Mary’s deteriorating mental state.

What really struck me about this film, beyond the spooky supernatural stuff, was how effectively it portrayed a woman’s very real fears in a totally isolating situation. It wasn’t just about ghosts; it was about the unsettling ways the men around her behaved. Her neighbor, John Linden, was just…creepy, constantly pushing himself on her. And it was awful seeing her go to a psychiatrist who basically dismissed her genuine terror as just being overly emotional. Even the minister at work seemed more concerned with appearances than actually helping her. These guys were honestly as frightening as any monster in the movie, and it made her vulnerability feel so much more intense.

Returning to life is surprisingly difficult for Mary, and she finds the everyday world – especially the men she encounters – nearly as challenging as being dead. She’s emotionally distant and doesn’t shy away from admitting she prefers to be alone. This was a conscious decision by the writer, John Clifford, as he explained in a 1996 interview with film historian Tom Weaver.

The film feels like a hazy dream, putting you right inside the main character’s confusing reality. At times, she’s incredibly present and draws everyone’s attention and concern. But then, she completely fades away, becoming lost and invisible, as if she’s trapped in a different world.

Carnival of Souls is a deeply unsettling film that evokes feelings of loneliness and detachment. It deliberately makes viewers feel as isolated as the main character, allowing them to experience her alienation firsthand. Mary, the protagonist, poignantly states, “I don’t belong in the world… something separates me from other people,” a line that has resonated through the years and was even sampled by Lana Del Rey.

The Lynchian Spirit of Carnival of Souls

Had *Carnival of Souls* come out years later, it likely would have been called “Lynchian.” The film’s dreamlike rhythm, odd and distant acting, and eerie sound effects strongly foreshadow the unique and captivating strangeness that David Lynch would later become known for.

David Lynch himself has mentioned this film as a significant inspiration, and the similarity was obvious enough that film critic Roger Ebert pointed it out in his 1989 review. Ebert observed that the film evokes the same sense of hidden darkness beneath the calm exterior of small-town life as ‘Blue Velvet.’ This highlights the film’s central theme: a compelling interest in the strange and unsettling things hidden within the ordinary.

The film *Carnival of Souls* brilliantly establishes this concept through its main setting: a run-down, deserted carnival pavilion. While simply a decaying building in reality, the film transforms it into a bizarre place where normal rules don’t apply. This echoes David Lynch’s technique of taking ordinary locations – like a diner or a street in *Mulholland Drive* – and turning them into unsettling, mysterious spaces.

The creepy figure known as “The Man,” who stalks Mary and was actually played by the director, Herk Harvey, feels like a clear inspiration for unsettling characters in films like David Lynch’s *Lost Highway*, particularly the Mystery Man. This surprising connection between Harvey and Lynch highlights just how innovative and forward-thinking Harvey’s film really was.

How a $33,000 Film Became a Cult Classic

Despite being a creatively impressive film, *Carnival of Souls* didn’t succeed at the box office. It was made in Kansas by filmmakers who usually worked on industrial projects, and it started with just one striking image. Director Harvey only asked the screenwriter to make sure the ending featured a large group of ghostly figures dancing in a ballroom. After a distributor heavily edited it for drive-in theaters, the film faded into obscurity.

Despite its strange and unsettling style, the film proved too compelling to be forgotten. It was brought back into the spotlight in the 1980s through frequent showings on late-night television, where it gained a new fanbase and began to develop its now-famous cult status. Its impact on the genre is clear today. While strongly connected to the work of David Lynch, the film also directly influenced another artist.

As a huge horror fan, I’ve always been fascinated by the zombies in George A. Romero’s *Night of the Living Dead*. What really struck me was how different they were from the monsters I’d seen before – they weren’t fast and scary, but slow, shuffling, and almost…sad. Apparently, Romero got the idea for that look from a really cool, low-budget film called *Carnival of Souls*. Those ghouls were pale, quiet, and moved slowly too, and he clearly used them as inspiration for his iconic zombies!

Even Roger Ebert recognized the influence, pointing out that a scene of ghostly figures at a deserted amusement park echoed imagery from another film. This demonstrates that this little-known movie from Kansas subtly inspired the visual style of two major figures in modern horror.

The film continues to inspire filmmakers today. Argentine director Lucrecia Martel, acclaimed for movies like *Headless Woman* (2008) and *Zama* (2017), has praised it as “brilliant,” saying, “This is a crucial reminder for all of us filmmakers… achieving something like this is enough. It captures everything I find most frightening in life, and I can’t even watch it by myself.”

Though it wasn’t made with a large budget or well-known actors, this film possessed something far more important: a strikingly original and unsettling artistic style. Its ending is a powerful and heartbreaking culmination of a story that constantly explores the boundary between life and death. Like many classic films, *Carnival of Souls* remains unforgettable and continues to resonate with audiences.

Read More

2025-10-16 01:40