Dead Space Was Killed (Twice) and No One Has Been Able to Pick up the Torch

Dead Space initially drew inspiration from games and films like *Resident Evil 4*, *Event Horizon*, *The Thing* (1982), and *Alien*, but it quickly evolved into something uniquely its own. Thanks to its memorable protagonist and innovative gameplay, Dead Space distinguished itself and made a significant impact on the genre.

Electronic Arts unfortunately cancelled the Dead Space series, and then, true to form, did so again about ten years later. While the franchise has been revived and cancelled multiple times, nothing has quite captured its unique appeal, which says a lot about the current state of the gaming industry.

Dead Space Came at the Right Place at the Right Time

The creation of *Dead Space* came about because some developers wanted to steer away from Electronic Arts’ focus on sequels and games based on existing franchises. Executive producer Glen Schofield had previously worked on movie tie-ins like *The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King* and *007: From Russia With Love*, and then *System Shock 3*, a project that changed direction after the team was heavily influenced by *Resident Evil 4*. Instead of just pitching the idea, they showed EA a playable demo, which convinced the publisher to take a risk and approve the new game, a departure from their usual cautious approach.

The game *Dead Space* built on the success of *Resident Evil 4* at a time when Capcom wasn’t producing strong titles. Its innovative combat system, which focused on strategically dismembering enemies, wasn’t just a gimmick; it genuinely amplified the tension and fear that defines survival horror. As art director Ian Milham explained, the gameplay perfectly captured the stressful feeling of needing to make precise actions under intense pressure – much like a character in a horror movie desperately fumbling with keys while being pursued by a threat.

Unlike many games of its time, *Dead Space* moved away from traditional fixed-camera ‘headshot’ aiming, opting for a more fluid and action-oriented control scheme. This design choice tied into the game’s telekinetic abilities, rewarding skillful players who could utilize their surroundings – like explosive barrels or detached monster claws – to conserve resources. The ability to move while shooting also set *Dead Space* apart from games like *Resident Evil*, which emphasized static, deliberate aiming. Importantly, this new approach didn’t sacrifice any of the game’s intensity. Combined with a detailed and well-developed universe, *Dead Space* felt remarkably polished and cohesive for a first game. According to creator Josh Schofield, quality and innovation were central to the game’s design, and that commitment is clearly visible in the final product.

Visceral Games had a strong track record with its excellent *Dead Space* sequel and surprisingly fun spin-off, but corporate interference ultimately damaged that success. Attempts to make the games more mainstream, combined with budget cuts, forced microtransactions, and a shift away from the original horror focus, hurt *Dead Space 3* and led to its failure, even though the idea for a next game was promising. This disappointing conclusion left the series open for a potential revival, similar to how *Dead Space* had once filled a gap when *Resident Evil* was struggling.

The Callisto Protocol Was Not the Spiritual Sequel Dead Space Deserved

With a team of developers who previously worked on *Dead Space*, *The Callisto Protocol* looked like a strong contender to fill the void left by that series. The game was a frightening, space-based horror experience, and interestingly, it revisited an early concept from *Dead Space* – a player character who begins the story as a prisoner. However, despite the developer’s repeated claims of prioritizing quality, that commitment didn’t fully translate into the final product.

Although the game’s creator, Schofield, mentioned publisher pressure led to a rushed release, the issues with *The Callisto Protocol* go much deeper than just the timing. Clunky controls and simple gameplay made the combat feel tedious, and it failed to deliver genuine scares. The story also became increasingly predictable and drawn-out. Ultimately, *The Callisto Protocol* lacked the strong storytelling and clever design that made *Dead Space* so successful. Combined with a disappointing expansion and a significantly reduced development team, it seems unlikely the studio will be able to create a similar, impactful horror game in the future.

Despite the critical and commercial success of the 2023 *Dead Space* remake, Electronic Arts has once again shelved the franchise. This came quickly after the remake’s release and not long after the disappointing performance of the similar game, *Callisto*. The remake was widely praised for being a standout example of how to revitalize a classic, blending new ideas with the original’s strengths, but it wasn’t enough to secure the series’ future. EA reassigned the remake’s developer, Motive Studio, to work on the safer, though less inspiring, *Iron Man* and *Battlefield 6*. It’s a frustrating parallel, as Visceral Games was similarly moved to the underwhelming *Battlefield Hardline* following the difficulties with *Dead Space 3*. Now, with the *Dead Space* team scattered and plans for a sequel seemingly on hold, another studio could potentially take on the challenge of continuing the series.

Cronos: The New Dawn Was Yet Another Terrible Attempt at Dead Space

With Cronos: The New Dawn, Bloober Team aimed to create another compelling horror experience. After successfully remaking Silent Hill 2, the studio generated excitement with the announcement of Cronos. The initial trailer clearly showed the game’s inspiration from Dead Space – a futuristic, armored protagonist battling strange, monstrous creatures – a connection the developers later confirmed.

I really wanted to like *Cronos*, but it was a huge disappointment. Like with *Callisto* before it, the initial ideas seemed promising, but the final game just didn’t deliver. It wasn’t scary, the combat was a mess – I was constantly running out of resources, enemies barely reacted to my attacks, and the monster merging mechanic felt totally pointless. They talked it up as being about strategic dismemberment, but it really wasn’t. The world had potential, but the main character was bland, the story felt overly cynical, and that final plot twist came completely out of left field. Honestly, it felt like Bloober Team fell back into some old, uninspired habits.

The chances of getting another game like Dead Space feel slim these days. The video game industry has changed a lot recently, with many company leaders prioritizing quick profits over long-term vision. Survival horror games aren’t hugely popular, and publishers are hesitant to invest in projects that might not deliver massive returns. When the Dead Space remake was first planned, things looked promising. The success of games like *Resident Evil 2* and *The Last of Us Part II*, combined with increased player spending during the pandemic, suggested a good opportunity. However, as life returned to normal, those early pandemic investments – like EA’s cancelled Black Panther game – became much riskier, leading to widespread layoffs across the industry.

A New Dead Space (Or “Dead Space”) Seems Unlikely

A sale of Electronic Arts (EA) seems very likely, and it probably means we won’t see another Dead Space game. If the sale goes through, EA will be heavily in debt – around $20 billion – and could even face a $1 billion penalty if the deal falls apart. Companies with that much debt usually focus on games that will make a lot of money quickly, and single-player horror games aren’t typically big earners. While EA might try to sell the Dead Space franchise, many publishers tend to acquire properties and then do nothing with them.

Creating another horror game like *Callisto Protocol* is currently difficult due to a lack of funding. Glen Schofield recently shared that his pitch for a new *Dead Space* game was rejected by EA, and generally, large-scale funding for new games is scarce. *Callisto Protocol* itself was reportedly very expensive to make, costing around $160 million. Given its poor performance, publisher Krafton is unlikely to invest that much in another horror game anytime soon. Across the industry, publishers are prioritizing well-known franchises, especially as the economic situation worsens, particularly in the United States.

There’s room in the market for a smaller studio to make a horror game similar to *Dead Space*, but it’s a tough ask. A smaller team would need to carefully manage the game’s scope, and with budgets tight across the gaming industry, it’s unlikely to happen. While *Cronos* fit that mold, the studio Bloober Team doesn’t have the experience or skill to consistently deliver quality mid-range horror games, especially not anything like a new *Silent Hill*.

It’s becoming increasingly difficult to create a new horror game like Dead Space. Financial pressures within the gaming industry and risk-averse decision-making from company executives are making it hard for these kinds of games to succeed outside of companies like Capcom and Sony. It’s unlikely we’ll see a truly great, smaller-scale horror game from a less established studio, or that a major developer will get the necessary funding and time to create a proper Dead Space sequel or a similarly ambitious new game. Instead, it feels like the series will only continue through small references and expensive in-game items, allowing the franchise to generate profit without meaningful support – a bit like exploiting a resource until nothing is left.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/gaming/news/silent-hill-f-series-best-22-years-breaks-free-sh2-grip/embed/#

2025-10-10 06:41

Dead Space Came at the Right Place at the Right Time

The Callisto Protocol Was Not the Spiritual Sequel Dead Space Deserved

Cronos: The New Dawn Was Yet Another Terrible Attempt at Dead Space

A New Dead Space (Or “Dead Space”) Seems Unlikely

Read More