Dune 3’s Shocking Casting Choice May Repeat A Major Dune 2 Change

by

As a devoted cinephile, I’m thrilled to share some exciting news about the casting for “Dune: Part Three.” This announcement hints at potential adaptational similarities between the upcoming “Dune Messiah” and changes made in “Dune: Part Two.” Notably, Anya Taylor-Joy, who captivated audiences with her performance in “Dune: Part Two,” will reprise her role as the older Alia Atreides in the sequel.

In Dune: Part Two, Anya Taylor-Joy’s role was enjoyable, but it puzzled some Dune enthusiasts because the character hadn’t been born yet in the storyline. Since Alia remains a child for quite some time after birth in the Dune book series, the movie needed an innovative solution to make her appear older for her end-of-film appearance.

As a passionate cinephile, I’d express it like this: In the intricate tapestry of Denis Villeneuve’s vision for Dune: Part Two, I’ve noticed an additional foreshadowing element that caught my attention. This time, Paul Atreides gets a glimpse into the future, seeing an older version of Alia, portrayed by Anya Taylor-Joy. In this premonition, Alia is seen on a water-filled Arrakis, subtly nudging Paul forward in his journey, hinting at what lies ahead in his grand plan.

Paul’s Children In Dune 3 Could Be Copying Dune 2’s Alia Atreides Change

Paul Could See Them In A Vision

The shift in the character of Alia in “Dune: Part Two” might seem peculiar, but it could potentially shed light on the enigma surrounding the casting decision for “Dune: Part Three”. It’s been disclosed that Nakoa-Wolf Momoa and Ida Brooke will portray Paul and Chani’s offspring in the third movie, with them taking on the roles of Leto II and Ghanima respectively.

Interestingly, there seems to be a discrepancy regarding the actors’ ages. In contrast to Leto II and Ghanima from Dune Messiah who are just born in the movie, these actors appear to be approximately 16 years old. However, this age doesn’t align with their roles in Dune: Part Three, as per the storyline, they should be much younger due to their births happening within the narrative of the film.

Part Three”, Leto II and Ghanima might predominantly be portrayed by child actors. However, these adult actors may only make brief appearances in scenes hinting at future events.

Other Explanations For Paul’s Kids Being So Much Older In Dune 3

Could Dune 3 Adapt Children Of Dune?

Part Three”. One plausible scenario is that the third film could delve into the events of “Children of Dune”, where the kids are indeed older. Given that Villeneuve’s “Dune” series will conclude with this movie, it might be his intention to cover both storylines simultaneously.

Part Three”. Alternatively, the characters could be made older, but theories suggest that combining the stories is more in line with the franchise’s history.

Read More

2025-07-06 21:50