Every Version of Invasion of the Body Snatchers, Ranked

by

Jack Finney’s novel, The Body Snatchers, proved to be remarkably easy to adapt for different films and shows, especially for its time. The story takes place in a small town, and what makes it unique is that the villains aren’t traditional scary aliens – they’re perfect copies of people. This allowed filmmakers to create suspense with a lower budget, focusing on the characters and building a sense of paranoia. It’s terrifying because the enemy looks just like everyone else, making it hard to know who to trust or where to run. While there have been four adaptations of the 1954 novel, some have been more successful than others.

Adaptations of The Body Snatchers consistently prove successful. You might think a story like this could only be told once, but it’s actually been effectively revisited by different filmmakers across generations, each using the core idea to reflect their own time and society. So, which version is the best? Let’s take a look.

4) The Invasion

The film The Invasion feels completely impersonal, much like one of those emotionless duplicates you see in old sci-fi movies. Except here, instead of aliens, the problem is a contagious disease spread by a fungus from outer space. That’s the main way the director, Oliver Hirschbiegel, tries to put a new spin on the classic invasion story.

While it’s good that The Invasion attempted something different, it unfortunately removes all the suspense. Previous Invasion of the Body Snatchers films effectively showed how much danger the characters were in and how increasingly powerless they became. This version, however, immediately establishes that Nicole Kidman’s character is a doctor who will likely find a cure, and that’s exactly what happens. This makes everything that happens in the movie feel pointless. Ultimately, that’s a fair assessment of the film itself.

3) Body Snatchers

While The Invasion and Abel Ferrara’s Body Snatchers are noticeably different in quality, Body Snatchers is a significant improvement over both and nearly as good as the very best versions of the story. Moving the setting really helps the film, though some of the characters aren’t particularly engaging.

The idea of setting a story about emotionless villains on an army base, instead of in a typical small town, is fresh and effective. However, the film’s central family, the Malones, aren’t particularly interesting. Despite this, the movie builds genuinely scary tension, has a dreamlike visual style, and contains some truly surprising moments.

2) Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956)

Invasion of the Body Snatchers, like many sci-fi horror films from that time, skillfully creates a believable small-town atmosphere. It’s particularly effective at taking that wholesome, Andy Griffith Show-type setting and turning it into something unsettling and frightening.

The original film excels in many ways, particularly thanks to Kevin McCarthy’s flawless performance – though Donald Sutherland is also excellent, McCarthy truly shines as the lead. The script is also remarkably strong. While it ranks second on this list, the 1956 film is still a genre-defining masterpiece, blending elements of several different types of storytelling.

Stream Invasion of the Body Snatchers on MGM+.

1) Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1978)

Philip Kaufman’s Invasion of the Body Snatchers is considered one of the most frightening films from the 1970s and stands out as a truly exceptional remake. While it closely follows the story of the original, it creates an even more unsettling and creepy mood. It also introduced the now-iconic ‘point and scream’ effect of the pod people, which was later revisited in the film Body Snatchers.

The film’s ending is incredibly shocking – it’s hard to think of a more unsettling conclusion to a horror movie. It’s a masterful scene that proves the audience’s constant feeling of unease was completely justified throughout the entire film.

Stream Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1978) on HBO Max.

Read More

2025-11-22 03:44