I’m Worried About The Lord Of The Rings Franchise

by

It’s rare for any fantasy movie series to reach the success of The Lord of the Rings trilogy. Peter Jackson’s films were a remarkable accomplishment – a sweeping, moving, and visually stunning story that redefined fantasy on film. Even now, over twenty years later, very few franchises have captured the same sense of wonder.

As a huge Tolkien fan, it felt like things were quiet in Middle-earth for a long time after The Battle of the Five Armies came out in 2014. But then, in the last few years, it’s been amazing! We’ve gotten The Rings of Power on Prime Video, the animated The War of the Rohirrim from Warner Bros., and there’s even a live-action The Hunt for Gollum on the way. Honestly, there’s more happening with the franchise now than ever before!

Expanding the world of The Lord of the Rings is risky. Because fans deeply cherish the original movies and J.R.R. Tolkien’s books, the recent wave of new projects—each with its own take on Middle-earth—feels like a big gamble that could alienate them.

The Lord Of The Rings Franchise Is In A Weird Position Right Now

Middle-earth’s New Era Is Full Of Ambition, But Also Confusion

The Lord of the Rings franchise is at a critical point. While audiences still crave epic fantasy, the future of the series feels uncertain. Recent projects have been inconsistent in their style and storytelling, lacking a clear, cohesive creative direction.

As a lifelong fan of Middle-earth, I’m excited to see so much new content – The Rings of Power, The War of the Rohirrim, and now The Hunt for Gollum! But honestly, I’m also a little worried. It feels like these new shows and movies are starting to move pretty far away from the heart of Tolkien’s stories, and I fear they might lose some of the original fans. The original trilogy felt so respectful of the source material, but these adaptations are really pushing the limits of what feels ‘true’ to Middle-earth, both in how things look and what actually happens.

Both Warner Bros. and Amazon understand there’s still a strong audience for stories set in Middle-earth, but their recent projects feel driven by business goals rather than artistic vision. While revisiting Tolkien’s work isn’t a problem, these new adaptations seem focused on offering unique interpretations, which ultimately creates a disjointed and inconsistent experience.

The Lord of the Rings series is in a curious position today. While it remains a major part of our culture, recent additions haven’t lived up to the quality of the original stories. To regain its former popularity, the franchise needs to recapture the heart and focused storytelling that once made it so beloved.

The War Of The Rohirrim Was A Disappointing Comeback For The Saga

The Long-Awaited Animated Return To Middle-earth Didn’t Deliver The Magic Fans Hoped For

The new movie, The War of the Rohirrim, was expected to be a great return for The Lord of the Rings franchise in theaters. Taking place 200 years before The Fellowship of the Ring, the film tells the story of Helm Hammerhand (played by Brian Cox), the famous king known for Helm’s Deep, and his daughter, Héra (Gaia Wise).

Despite high hopes, The War of the Rohirrim didn’t quite succeed. Reviews were mixed, and many fans found it disappointing. The film attempted a unique animation style, blending anime with the realistic look of Middle-earth, but this didn’t always come across smoothly.

The story didn’t have the same emotional impact or detailed world as Jackson’s movies, making it feel less significant than a main installment and more like an unnecessary addition. Beyond a weak plot – especially when compared to The Lord of the Rings – the biggest problem was the overall tone.

As a big Tolkien fan, I really wanted to love The War of the Rohirrim, and it had moments, but it just didn’t quite hit the mark for me. The characters, like Helm and Héra, were okay, but they didn’t feel as deep or fully realized as the ones we know and love from The Lord of the Rings. While the music and animation were good in places, they didn’t fully capture that amazing, epic feeling of Middle-earth. It felt like something was missing to truly make it feel like a part of that world.

The film The War of the Rohirrim wasn’t necessarily bad, but it was disappointingly ordinary. Considering how consistently high-quality the Lord of the Rings franchise has been, that’s not good enough. After waiting almost ten years for a new theatrical release, fans hoped for something truly remarkable. Instead, the film felt empty, lacking the emotional resonance and epic scope that define Middle-earth.

The Rings Of Power Has Yet To Live Up To The Expectations

Amazon’s Billion-Dollar Series Has The Scale, But Not The Soul, Of Peter Jackson’s Movies

Both The War of the Rohirrim and The Lord of the Rings are back in the spotlight with Amazon’s The Rings of Power. The new series aimed to be a grand prequel, delving into Tolkien’s Second Age – including the creation of the Rings, Sauron’s ascent to power, and the destruction of Númenor. It sounded perfect for fans of The Lord of the Rings, but the actual series has proven to be quite complex.

The series is visually stunning, and Morfydd Clark is excellent as Galadriel. However, beautiful visuals aren’t enough to save it from other issues. The Rings of Power feels tonally inconsistent and lacks a strong emotional core. The story moves at an uneven pace, the conversations feel shallow, and the attempts to build suspense often feel artificial.

The biggest weakness of the show wasn’t a lack of scope, but how the story was told. While The Rings of Power featured a large cast and many different plot threads, most of the characters didn’t feel particularly memorable. Compared to the emotional depth and relatable characters in Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings films, the TV series feels distant and lacks heart. It’s visually stunning, but rarely emotionally engaging.

Look, I really want to love The Rings of Power. There’s still hope for future seasons if they can streamline the story and really dig into what makes the characters tick. But honestly, after all the hype, it hasn’t quite earned its place alongside Peter Jackson’s movies yet. It’s visually stunning, absolutely, but it’s lacking that emotional core – that real heart – that made The Lord of the Rings so special and unforgettable.

The Hunt For Gollum Is A Strange Addition To The Lord Of The Rings Franchise

Gollum’s Story Feels More Complete Than Any Other Character’s, So Why Go Back?

Of all the new Lord of the Rings projects being made, The Hunt for Gollum is perhaps the most unusual. Warner Bros. has announced it as the next big movie set in Middle-earth, and it will star Andy Serkis as Gollum again – this time, he’s also directing. While that sounds promising, it also leaves many wondering what the film will actually be like.

Gollum’s story has a definitive ending, and his death in the original trilogy provided a powerful emotional core. Focusing a new movie on his past – his pursuit of the Ring and being hunted by characters like Aragorn, Sauron, and Gandalf – could diminish the intrigue that made him such a captivating character.

The film’s creative choice is also a bit strange. Rather than delve into the many unexplored periods of Tolkien’s world, The Hunt for Gollum revisits a character we’ve seen a lot already. It feels more like a trip down memory lane than a story that truly adds something new.

Despite the concerns, Andy Serkis’s participation – along with the return of actors like Ian McKellen as Gandalf – offers a glimmer of optimism. He truly understands the complex and troubled mind of Gollum. However, this project feels like a gamble; it could either enrich the world of Middle-earth or diminish its legacy, and it’s hard to predict which outcome is more likely.

Do We Really Need More Lord Of The Rings Movies?

Middle-earth Was Already Perfect. If It Must Return, It Has To Earn It.

It’s fair to wonder if we really need another Lord of the Rings film. The original trilogy is a true masterpiece, and Peter Jackson’s version beautifully told a complete and moving story, from the humble courage of Frodo and Sam to Aragorn’s inspiring journey. It’s hard to imagine how a new film could add anything meaningful.

Although the Hobbit movies weren’t always consistent, they were enjoyable and created a detailed world. These six films together presented a complete and fulfilling adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien’s stories. Trying to make more movies based on this material would likely offer less and less value.

Even though many are doubtful, there’s still a chance for the franchise to succeed. If the new team can creatively build on the existing story in a respectful way – avoiding excessive explanations or relying too heavily on past memories – it could be revitalized. Fans aren’t just looking for more content set in Middle-earth; they want additions that feel significant and worthwhile.

I’m still hopeful, but being realistic. Tolkien’s stories have always been about believing even when things are uncertain, and that’s exactly what we need right now as we wait to see what happens with future Lord of the Rings movies.

Read More

2025-11-09 03:11