New Mystery Thriller Series With 77% on RT Officially Breaks Streaming Record With 46 Million Views

Peacock’s new limited series, featuring Sarah Snook, Dakota Fanning, and Jake Lacey, has become its most popular show ever. In just three weeks, it reached 46 million views, surpassing all previous streaming records on the platform. It continues to rank among the top five most-watched original series in the U.S.

“All Her Fault” is a limited series inspired by a true story from Andrea Mara. It follows Marissa Irvine, a working mother, when she goes to collect her son, Milo, from a playdate only to find the host claims to have never met them. This sets off a frantic search as Marissa and her husband, aided by Marissa’s friend Jenny, desperately try to find Milo. As they search, they uncover hidden family secrets that will change both their lives forever.

It’s A Great Watch For Fans Of Thrillers

The show has received generally positive reviews, with particular praise for the performances of Snook and Fanning. Megan Andersen from Common Sense Media highlights the show’s compelling combination of a mother’s worst nightmare, strong writing, and acting, alongside its stylish and modern visuals set against the backdrop of Chicago. Lucy Mangen of The Guardian notes that the story builds beautifully, with all plot points coming together smoothly, and keeps viewers engaged long after the initial premise grabs their attention.

While the show’s rhythm is uneven at times and some plot points stretch believability, the acting is fantastic, and the surprising ending ultimately makes everything worthwhile. All Her Fault also thoughtfully explores the importance of the relationships and communities we create, particularly among women. It’s deliberately over-the-top and dramatic—even the most grounded characters lean into heightened performances—but this stylistic choice enhances the incredibly engaging and twist-filled story.

Did you enjoy watching All Her Fault? Share your favorite moment from the show in the comments below! Then, join the conversation and see what other fans are discussing on the ComicBook forum.

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/news/everything-coming-to-peacock-in-december-2025/embed/#

Read More

2025-12-13 23:41