
In the eerie atmosphere of “Freak Show” or the politically turbulent setting of “Cult”, these warped portrayals transcend mere entertainment and successfully evoke deep-seated terror on various levels. However, some stood out more prominently than others. Here’s a ranking of all the clowns from “American Horror Story”. Which one is the scariest? Which one went relatively unnoticed?
In descending order of fear factor:
1. Twisty the Clown (Freak Show) – Known for his terrifying appearance, creepy demeanor, and gruesome past, this character is widely considered the scariest clown in “American Horror Story”.
2. Dandy Mott (Freak Show) – With his refined yet twisted personality and unsettling charm, Dandy’s portrayal of a disturbed collector of freaks adds to his menacing presence.
3. Clown Killer (Cult) – Although not officially identified as a clown, this character’s disturbing actions and masked identity make him one of the most unsettling figures in “American Horror Story”.
4. Clown Ally’s hallucination (Cult) – A manifestation of Ally’s fears, this clown represents her struggle with mental health issues and is a haunting reminder of her traumatic experiences.
5. Pepper’s imaginary friend (Freak Show) – Despite being a source of comfort for Pepper, her imaginary friend also serves as a symbol of her isolation and loneliness, adding to the overall eerie atmosphere.
6. The Clowns from the circus massacre (Freak Show) – While not particularly standout characters, their role in the circus massacre scene creates an unsettling and terrifying environment.
7. The clown at the carnival (Cult) – Although he appears briefly, this character adds to the chaotic atmosphere of the carnival setting without leaving a lasting impact on viewers.