Many Star Trek fans consider the original series to be the best, and deeply admire Captain Kirk, Spock, Dr. McCoy, and the crew of the first Enterprise. Actors like William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy remain iconic figures in the franchise. However, some viewers are beginning to notice flaws in the original series, and questioning whether these characters are as perfect as often believed. One common criticism centers around the first Star Trek movie.
This Star Trek film is less about action and more about thoughtful ideas, staying true to the original spirit of the show. However, some viewers have pointed out that Captain Kirk comes across as harsh in his treatment of his crew. One Reddit user noted that he seems unnecessarily cruel when making fun of McCoy’s fear of transporters, especially considering people had just died using one.
Star Trek Fans Realize Captain Kirk Was a Jerk
In Star Trek: The Motion Picture, a transporter accident happens early in the film. At the start, Captain Kirk has been promoted to admiral, and Captain Willard Decker is the new commander of the Enterprise. Starfleet sends the Enterprise to investigate a huge energy cloud, but first, the ship must pass a series of tests on its new systems. One of these tests involves the transporter, which isn’t working correctly. During a transport attempt, two officers, including the Vulcan science officer Sonak, are killed in a disturbing and frightening accident.
Immediately after the incident, Dr. Leonard McCoy expressed strong reservations about using the transporter, given that two people had just died during transport. When Captain Kirk questioned why, a crew member explained that McCoy wanted to observe it working first. As one online fan pointed out, Kirk responded with a knowing smirk, saying, “That sounds familiar.” This was a joke Kirk made right after the deaths, seemingly mocking McCoy’s cautiousness.
A lot of viewers started discussing whether a certain character flaw felt like a mistake in the movie, but many on Reddit pointed out it wasn’t a flaw in the film itself—it was a consistent part of the character’s personality. One commenter explained that the character often acts impatiently and critically, and the movie shows him needing to address this. They also noted an example of this behavior: he unfairly criticized Captain Decker immediately after Decker saved the entire ship.
You know, rewatching The Original Series and the movies with the original Star Trek crew, something really struck me. Captain Kirk has always had this tendency to think he’s right, and it’s pretty clear he doesn’t like being challenged. It made me think about the scene with Decker – after Kirk made that competitive remark, even Bones questioned if it was really about competition! And it led someone on Reddit to point out something brilliant: Spock and Bones basically were Kirk’s conscience. They were always there to try and keep him grounded, even if he didn’t always listen!
What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
Read More
- What Song Is In The New Supergirl Trailer (& What It Means For The DC Movie)
- TV legend Carol Kirkwood reveals the reasons why she decided to retire after 28 years with BBC
- Dune 3 Gets the Huge Update Fans Have Been Waiting For
- After 13 Years, Someone Earned One of the Hardest Achievement Trophies in Gaming
- Avengers: Doomsday Release Date Change Being Discussed – Report
- Grab These Resident Evil PSN Avatars for Free This Month
- Gold’s March Madness: Plumbing, Panic, and Polish Central Banks
- Whales, Channels, and the Inevitable Dance of Folly
- The War Film Harrison Ford Completely Disowned Finally Returns to Streaming – “A Terrible Experience”
- Steam Giving Away Two PC Games for Free for Next 72 Hours
2026-04-05 17:40