The DCU Is Already Doing Something Better Than The MCU Ever Did

by

The Marvel Cinematic Universe was initially based on an innovative idea: a vast narrative woven across interconnected movies. This groundbreaking approach significantly altered Hollywood and eventually led to the unparalleled achievement of the Infinity Saga. Yet, when Marvel attempted to extend this concept beyond films, the outcomes were frequently uneven. For quite some time, their television endeavors were regarded as secondary, resulting in a fragmented narrative that the studio continues to address. Later, when Marvel Studios returned their focus to TV productions, the outcome was often a crowded lineup of releases that struggled to uphold the concept of a shared universe.

Over the past decade, Warner Bros. has been attempting to match Marvel’s success with their DC properties, but their series of debatable movie choices often resulted in more failures than victories. For example, the failed DC Extended Universe was initiated with a long-term storyline that was ultimately dropped after films like “Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice” and “Justice League” (2017) received negative critical reception and disappointing box office results. This was followed by a scattered series of films due to frequent changes in direction and reactive decision-making. However, there were exceptions such as “Wonder Woman” and “Aquaman.” Unfortunately, the lack of a unified plan damaged audience trust, prompting a complete overhaul. Now, under the new management of James Gunn and Peter Safran, the DC Universe is being completely reimagined from its foundations.

The first trio of DCU projects – the acclaimed animated series ‘Creature Commandos’, the critically appreciated movie ‘Superman’ and the highly-praised second season of ‘Peacemaker’ live-action series – collectively serve as a persuasive blueprint for this new universe. The animated series received a remarkable 95% positive rating on Rotten Tomatoes, while the Superman film secured an impressive 83% Certified Fresh rating from critics. Moreover, the second season of ‘Peacemaker’ debuted with an almost flawless 97% score on Rotten Tomatoes, with several critics praising it as even surpassing the first season. Taken together, these three productions demonstrate the DCU‘s potential for weaving a cohesive narrative across various mediums, while consistently delivering top-notch quality. This initial success indicates that the DCU may be laying the groundwork for becoming the leading player in the realm of superhero media.

Marvel Studios’ Fractured Universe

In the initial phase of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), Marvel Studios, headed by Kevin Feige, and Marvel Television, led by Jeph Loeb, functioned independently under the parent company, Marvel Entertainment, owned by Ike Perlmutter. A significant conflict between Feige and Perlmutter caused a corporate reshuffle in 2015, transferring Marvel Studios to Walt Disney Studios, while Marvel Television remained unchanged. This divide produced a considerable gap in terms of both practicality and creativity, as the movies showed no reason or obligation to reference the television series, leading to a confusing “one-way narrative.

The Winter Soldier,” yet this significant event – the resurrection of Agent Phil Coulson (Clark Gregg), a key emotional element in the first “Avengers” movie – was overlooked by the film part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

In a similar vein, shows like “Daredevil” and “Jessica Jones,” both well-known on Netflix, often hinted at a major event in New York City without giving clear details. For quite some time, their status within the Marvel Universe was a topic of much discussion. However, with Marvel Studios’ recent decision to incorporate these shows into the main timeline – a move likely inspired by the upcoming “Daredevil: Born Again” reboot – this debate has come to an end.

After Marvel Television merged with Marvel Studios in 2019, giving Kevin Feige control over all productions, the issue of integration became more complex. Some Disney+ series have been criticized for serving as extended prequels to forthcoming films instead of offering self-contained stories that stand on their own. For example, the plot of “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness” heavily relies on the character development of Wanda Maximoff (Elizabeth Olsen) from “WandaVision,” which has left audiences who only watch movies puzzled. On the other hand, series like “Moon Knight” seem disconnected from the broader MCU, making their role in the overall storyline uncertain.

In terms of animated series, the approach has been to deliberately keep things distinct. Shows like “X-Men ’97” and “Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man” are clearly set apart from the main timeline, while shows like “What If…?” steer clear of directly influencing the primary storyline to maintain their multiverse focus. This consistent lack of integration often gives the Marvel Cinematic Universe a disjointed feel, as if it’s a group of standalone stories rather than one unified tale. However, at times, the connections between different productions are so strong that keeping up with each new Marvel Studios release feels like doing homework, a phenomenon even Feige acknowledges.

The DCU’s Blueprint for a New Era

In its early stages, the DCU (DC Universe) has an advantage over the MCU (Marvel Cinematic Universe) in terms of its shared universe. The animated series “Creature Commandos” introduced characters like Rick Flag Sr., portrayed by Frank Grillo, who later appeared in “Superman”, then became the main adversary in “Peacemaker” Season 2. This provides a coherent narrative arc across the initial three projects. Similarly, Nathan Fillion’s character, Guy Gardner, was introduced in “Superman” and is set to reappear in both “Peacemaker” Season 2 and the upcoming live-action series “Lanterns”. This strategic sharing of characters establishes a universe that feels consistently interwoven from the start, with major figures frequently appearing multiple times within a short span.

In the DC Universe (DCU), each project is carefully designed to offer a complete story on its own, meaning viewers can appreciate titles like “Superman” independently without needing to watch every related content. On the other hand, for those who wish to delve deeper into the narrative, the experience becomes even more rewarding. Moreover, the DCU boasts an impressive range of tones, with forthcoming releases such as the R-rated horror film “Clayface” and the animated series “Dynamic Duo” promising unique experiences while maintaining consistency within the same continuity.

As a cinephile, I must say, the new direction at DC Studios seems to have tackled two major challenges that the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) has been grappling with lately. Unlike diving into the DCEU, it no longer feels like I’m gearing up for a pile of homework. Instead, each movie stands as an engaging narrative on its own merit. Yet, the beauty lies in how all these standalone stories interlock to form a larger, intriguing puzzle. By prioritizing narrative cohesion from the get-go, DC Studios is crafting a more immersive and captivating shared universe compared to what the MCU has managed so far.

What are your thoughts on the DC Universe up until now? Could it potentially outshine the Marvel Cinematic Universe? Share your views in the comments below!

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/news/best-first-premiere-episodes-marvel-tv-shows-mcu/embed/#

Read More

2025-08-19 19:19