The Penguin’s Cristin Milioti to Star in Horror Movie from Too Many Cooks Creator

by

Cristin Milioti, who’s been praised significantly for her portrayal of Sofia Gigante in HBO’s “The Penguin,” is preparing for her next significant role. This talented actress, who recently earned her first Primetime Emmy nomination for Outstanding Lead Actress in a DC series, will now be the lead in an upcoming horror movie named “Buddy.” Milioti’s captivating performance has garnered her recognition beyond borders, including Golden Globe and Critics’ Choice Television Award nominations, making her one of the season’s most intriguing performers. The series itself was a huge success for HBO, amassing an impressive 24 Emmy nominations, among which was one for Outstanding Limited or Anthology Series. As reported by Deadline, Milioti will shift from the crime-filled streets of Gotham to a mysterious genre project from a creator renowned for his chilling and viral content in her new endeavor.

The production for the movie titled “Buddy” has commenced, and it’s being hyped up as a fresh take on horror. This film is in the capable hands of director Casper Kelly, who collaborated with Jaime King on the script. Known for his 2014 viral hit “Too Many Cooks“, an 11-minute Adult Swim short that took the internet by storm, Kelly has a knack for subverting audience expectations. His work, such as the unexpected feature-length horror film “Adult Swim Yule Log“, demonstrates this talent. The Yule Log initially appeared as a simple holiday fireplace video before unveiling a complex narrative. Similarly, “Buddy” is expected to play with our expectations in the realm of horror.

The movie company that made “Buddy” is BoulderLight Pictures, known for producing recent horror successes such as “Barbarian” and the upcoming “Weapons.” This studio has become recognized for nurturing groundbreaking and imaginative horror productions, with “Weapons,” directed by Zach Cregger of “Barbarian” fame, being one of the most eagerly awaited horror films of 2025. This film is said to revolve around a horror epic involving the mysterious disappearance of elementary school children. Additionally, BoulderLight is working on a new movie inspired by the Amityville horror legend, collaborating with New Line Cinema to revive this classic franchise for a wider audience. Reports indicate that this project is moving quickly and will concentrate on the public domain aspects of the real-life paranormal tale, distinct from previous adaptations.

Will Cristin Milioti’s Sofia Gigante Appear in The Batman Sequel?

In the final scene of “The Penguin,” an opportunity arises for Sofia Gigante’s tale to unfold further, seamlessly linking her character to Matt Reeves’ version of Gotham City. As the show concludes with Sofia being falsely accused by Oz Cobb (Colin Farrell) and being committed to Arkham State Hospital, she receives an enigmatic letter from Selina Kyle, who claims to be Sofia’s sister. This plot twist mirrors the comics storyline of “Batman: The Long Halloween” and its sequel, “Dark Victory,” in which it is implied that Catwoman is the daughter of crime lord Carmine Falcone. Given Zoë Kravitz’s role as Catwoman in “The Batman,” this family connection paves the way for Sofia to be integrated into the storyline of “The Batman Part II.

Enthusiasts expecting the storyline from that thread to appear on the silver screen have good cause for optimism. Following a spell of low-key production which sparked some conjecture online, director Matt Reeves has confirmed that the script for “The Batman Part II,” jointly written with Mattson Tomlin, is now fully completed and submitted to DC Studios. This announcement has given the film a clear direction, aligning it with its planned October 1, 2027 release date. The second installment will unfold after the events of “The Penguin,” with the storyline intended to bridge the gap between the two films. Although no formal casting decisions beyond Pattinson and Farrell’s reprisals have been revealed, the suggestive link forged between Sofia and Selina in the finale of “The Penguin” suggests that Cristin Milioti’s commanding portrayal of the Gotham crime boss could significantly influence the narrative arc of this Batman series.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/things-still-dont-make-sense-the-batman-plot-holes/embed/#

Read More

2025-07-23 11:09