Why And Just Like That Must Finally Say Goodbye to Samantha Jones

by

When “And Just Like That” made its debut, nearly 18 years since the original series left viewers pondering which character they most identified with – Carrie, Samantha, Charlotte or Miranda – there were plenty of thoughts shared among the audience.

Although they did provide some entertainment, there was an unexpected lack of appeal about the original group at this point, not due to us encountering them in their later years, but rather because their work lacked the subtlety, keen insight, and logical structure found in the originals.

The efforts to mix up the show led to some issues with viewers, as Miranda’s character became increasingly out-of-touch and bumbling, and Che Diaz, who unexpectedly became one of the most controversial TV characters in recent times, despite being perceived as unfunny by many. This shift generated a sense of disconnect among the returning audience.

However much they’ve tried, the lack of Samantha Jones clearly demonstrates that And Just Like That isn’t just a replica of Sex and the City.

Or:

Despite their efforts, the absence of Samantha Jones underscores the fact that And Just Like That is not simply a carbon copy of Sex and the City.

We learned that Samantha left due to a disagreement with Carrie, following which she relocated to London, as the podcaster felt it was no longer appropriate for her to remain as Samantha’s publicist.

“She said ‘fine’ and then fired me as a friend,” explained Carrie.

However, following a period without contact, communication resumed between them upon the demise of Big. This was initiated by Samantha, who sent Carrie flowers and a heartfelt message saying, “Love, Samantha”.

After establishing a bond akin to friendship, there followed various pieces of text scattered around, and then came the grand announcement: Kim Cattrall will return to her role for the finale of season 2.

Cue dirty martinis being raised in jubilation up and down the land.

Initially, some speculated that showrunner Michael Patrick King might utilize Samantha’s short visit to write off her character due to his cryptic remarks. However, contrary to these anticipations, Samantha’s appearance turned out to be more of an uneventful occasion.

Instead of surprising Carrie by showing up at her old brownstone for the final dinner, Samantha’s flight got delayed, leaving only a short, delightful 90-second phone conversation as an alternative.

Indeed, even a whiff of Samantha was enough to reignite viewers’ enthusiasm about potentially seeing more of her, which eventually led Cattrall to announce that she wouldn’t feature in the series during its third season. This left any further involvement from her character confined to text messaging, alas.

Additionally, the recent installment featured more of this dynamic as Carrie reached out to Samantha to gather details about Duncan Reeves, a well-known biographer who dislikes high heels.

When Carrie mentioned that he resides in the flat below hers, Samantha couldn’t help but let out one of her signature witty remarks.

“I wish he was under me,” she responded.

Peeking at Carrie’s phone showed they’ve been arranging times to talk, implying that past disagreements are now resolved. However, we haven’t witnessed these reconciliations; we only catch occasional glimpses, like finding crumbs after a meal.

Perhaps, Samantha’s supposed demise could have been more palatable for two reasons. Firstly, this turn of events might be considered less contentious compared to Samantha and Carrie having a falling out over something that seems less likely to have deeply affected Samantha, given it doesn’t appear to be something she would have responded to so intensely, such as cutting off all communication.

Moreover, it’s important to note that Samantha, often seen as Sex and the City’s standout character by many viewers, will not be featured in And Just Like That.

As a devoted viewer, I must admit that the recent seasons of Sex and the City have had their ups and downs, but every time Samantha’s text appears on Carrie’s phone, it serves as a stark reminder of the vibrant life she’s living elsewhere. Her witty comebacks, bold spirit, unique friendships, and distinctive perspective on life continue to captivate us, leaving us longing for more of her dazzling antics.

Of course, King was eager to have Cattrall return, but he can’t force her decision not to be involved any longer. She has the right to make that choice for whatever reason. However, what he can manage is steering the show in a new direction.

It’s not about eliminating Samantha, Honey. No one could ever accomplish that. However, receiving those occasional messages is like sitting in a gleaming pink Cadillac and gripping the steering wheel, just to be abruptly kicked out moments later, or savoring a piece of red velvet cake, only for it to be taken away after a few delicious bites.

King’s occasional inclusion of Samantha commentary seems logical, but it doesn’t enrich And Just Like That significantly. Instead, it might even diminish the show, as it redirects focus towards real-life cast dynamics, and underscores what the series lacks: a unique character unlike any other.

Now that Cattrall and Samantha have both moved on, it’s time for And Just Like That to do the same.

And Just Like That… season 3 is showing on Sky Comedy and NOW.

Consider adding “And Just Like That…” to your list of shows to watch on TopMob’s What to Watch application – available for download today, offering personalized daily TV suggestions and exclusive content!

Read More

2025-06-27 05:34