25 Years Ago, PS2 Fans Got Their Answer to Legend of Zelda

The PlayStation 2 has one of the best game collections ever seen on a console, boasting a huge number of classic titles released during its time. While many of these games made already popular series even better or became beloved cult hits, quite a few other great games unfortunately got overlooked.

Released in North America in 2001, Dark Cloud was a promising action RPG with fantasy and adventure elements. Its mix of exploring worlds and fast-paced combat felt similar to the hugely popular The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time. Now, 25 years later, it’s interesting to revisit what made Dark Cloud a unique alternative to the Nintendo classic, and to consider why this series, which had the potential to be Sony’s answer to Zelda, only lasted for two games.

Dark Cloud Was An Underrated Classic Of The PS2 Era

Released in North America on May 29, 2001, Dark Cloud was a fantasy adventure game for the PlayStation 2 where players controlled a character named Toan. This action-packed RPG, played from a third-person view, offered a compelling fantasy experience. It was a strong response from Sony to The Legend of Zelda, and stood as a worthy competitor to Nintendo’s popular series. The game’s story centers around the chaos caused by Colonel Flag Giligster, who accidentally unleashes the incredibly powerful Dark Genie, leading to the destruction of villages throughout the land.

Toan is a survivor from the ruined town of Norune, and the Fairy King has given him a powerful magical stone called the Atamilla. His mission: travel the world and rebuild villages that have been mysteriously turned into glowing orbs called Alta. Dark Cloud, the first game from developer Level-5 (who later became famous for the Professor Layton series on Nintendo), was a large-scale fantasy adventure. It drew inspiration from popular games like The Legend of Zelda, particularly Ocarina of Time, sharing many similar features.

The game puts you in the role of Toan, who travels a vast world, finding strong weapons and skills. He uses a sword to fight monsters in dungeons. But the game offers more than just combat! It features a unique “thirst” mechanic that makes dungeon exploration more challenging, and you can even rebuild destroyed villages, adding a city-building element to the gameplay.

Players could switch out characters during missions, adding more strategic options to gameplay. With a lengthy campaign—easily over 20 hours—and plenty of challenges, Dark Cloud was a thrilling game. It clearly drew inspiration from Ocarina of Time, particularly its combat system, but still managed to create its own unique feel. It had a lot of potential, which makes its lack of lasting popularity all the more unfortunate.

Why Dark Cloud Hasn’t Gotten A New Game Since 2003

When Dark Cloud was first released, it received generally positive reviews, scoring an 80/100 on Metacritic. While it didn’t quite reach the same critical acclaim as Ocarina of Time, it was considered a game of similar quality. Reviewers had mixed feelings about the graphics and some gameplay elements, but they praised the game’s ambition and careful design. Although Dark Cloud didn’t perform well in Japan, it became much more successful in other regions, particularly North America, where the popularity of the PlayStation 2 and the positive reception of Ocarina of Time helped boost its sales. This success led to a sequel, Dark Chronicle, which was released in America in 2003.

While Dark Chronicle kept the same basic gameplay as the first Dark Cloud, it told a new story with different characters. It improved upon the original game, fixing issues and polishing the visuals and unique mechanics, ultimately becoming more popular with both critics and players. Despite strong demand from fans for a third game, the series stalled. According to Polygon, this was mainly because Sony co-owns the rights to the series, preventing the developers from easily creating a sequel.

It’s unfortunate that the Dark Crystal series never reached its full potential, as it could have been a major draw for PlayStation, offering a compelling alternative to Nintendo’s popular Legend of Zelda. The games had already proven their ability to innovate in storytelling, with each installment taking a different approach while consistently improving the core gameplay. With advancements in technology, the unique gameplay elements – like building and exploring – could have been expanded into vast dungeons with larger groups or even a more in-depth town-building experience. It’s disappointing that, 25 years after the original Dark Cloud gained a dedicated following, we haven’t seen more from the series. Nevertheless, it remains a standout, yet often overlooked, gem in the PlayStation 2’s collection.

Read More

2026-05-28 22:40