The Mt. Rushmore of Superheroes Has an Answer, But Marvel Fans Won’t Like It

by

The question of which superheroes are the most influential has been a long-running debate among fans of Marvel and DC Comics. A popular thought experiment asks us to imagine a ‘Mt. Rushmore’ of superheroes – if you could sculpt a monument to the four most important heroes of all time, who would they be? The responses people give are all over the map, from the expected choices to personal favorites and even some really unexpected ones.

I’ve noticed an interesting trend with how people are responding to this challenge online. Instead of trying to determine which heroes are most influential, many are simply making lists of their four favorites, which usually results in a pretty even mix of Marvel and DC characters. However, when people base their lists on a hero’s overall cultural impact, DC tends to dominate, and that bothers a lot of Marvel fans. Honestly, when you’re talking about the most iconic superheroes of all time – the ‘Mount Rushmore’ of the genre – DC’s biggest characters will always seem more important.

Superman, Wonder Woman, Batman, and Spider-Man are The Mt. Rushmore of Superheroes

Okay, I’ll be honest, I’m a huge DC Comics fan, so I’m definitely coming at this with a preference! But it’s not just because Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman are the most popular. Each one truly deserves a place on this monument. Superman, especially, changed everything when he first appeared. He basically created the modern superhero, and everyone wanted their own version after that. It kicked off a whole new era of storytelling that still impacts comics today – if that isn’t influential, I don’t know what is!

Wonder Woman and Batman didn’t become popular simply by being friends with Superman. Both heroes rose to prominence on their own merits. Batman quickly became a cultural icon, starring in countless successful movies, TV shows, video games, and animated series. Wonder Woman, meanwhile, broke barriers in the comic book industry, proving that superhero stories could appeal to everyone. Her success even inspired other publishers to create more diverse heroes beyond just male characters.

I enjoy DC Comics, but I appreciate heroes from other publishers too. If I had to pick one final spot on a ‘Mount Rushmore’ of superheroes, it would definitely be Spider-Man. He’s incredibly popular – practically everyone loves him! He’s been the face of Marvel Comics for decades, and his movies have earned billions of dollars. While Marvel has many great heroes, very few reach the same level of success and recognition as Spider-Man.

The Mt. Rushmore Experiment All Comes Down to Impact, Not Quality

Discussions like these often spark strong reactions because everyone judges success differently. Some people base their choices on personal connection – who they enjoyed or felt strongly about, and that’s perfectly fine. However, I see it as a question of which heroes have left the biggest mark on society. To be honest, I don’t think characters like Hulk or Wolverine have had as much broad cultural influence as Spider-Man, Superman, or Batman.

Marvel has a fantastic lineup of heroes, and during the peak of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Iron Man and Captain America were incredibly popular. While those characters still appear in comics and cartoons, DC Comics’ core heroes – Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman – and Spider-Man have remained consistently well-known across many generations. Most people’s parents, and even grandparents, recognize Batman and Wonder Woman, but fewer would know characters like Cyclops or Cyborg.

Very few superheroes have become truly iconic figures known around the globe. It’s not just about how long Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman, and Spider-Man have been around – they all possess a unique and captivating quality. While everyone has their favorites, I believe these four are the most deserving of being considered the ultimate superhero icons.

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/marvel-dc-just-stealth-dropped-2-new-crossovers-and-you-can-read-them-right-now/embed/#

Read More

2025-12-07 00:18