This Major Feature Is Threatening to Kill Marathon’s Potential

by

It’s incredibly frustrating when something almost reaches its full potential, but then falls short right at the end. You can sense something truly great forming, but a single choice prevents it from becoming truly exceptional.

Currently, what defines the game Marathon is how it handles player identity – or rather, doesn’t. Despite its excellent shooting and stylish look, a key feature could hold the game back. Marathon’s ‘Runner Shell’ system essentially makes it a hero shooter, which isn’t a great fit for the extraction genre. Instead of letting players create their own unique characters and roles, the game forces them into pre-made classes, which is a real letdown. For a game with so much potential, this feels like a big mistake.

Runner Shells Make Marathon Feel Like a Hero Shooter

Runner Shells were designed to be a simple way to define how players approach the game. Each Shell offers special abilities and perks that instantly impact a match. The idea was to create clear roles for players, encouraging teamwork and exciting gameplay. However, this system unintentionally turns Marathon into a hero shooter, even though that wasn’t the original goal. It’s a shame because Bungie could have given players more freedom to customize their experience, but they didn’t go far enough.

Hero shooters sometimes get a bad reputation, particularly in competitive gaming. The fixed abilities of each character can feel limiting. Instead of letting players freely experiment with different playstyles, these games often force you to pick a pre-defined character and stick with their set abilities. This changes how you approach and enjoy the game, shifting the focus from building a unique character to simply choosing one that already exists.

Honestly, one of the biggest things that pulls me out of the game is not being able to create my own character. It just doesn’t feel right. In a game where you’re supposed to be risking it all with a character you’ve built up, it feels… distant. I’m not becoming someone in this world, I’m just picking a pre-made operator. That’s fine for some games, but in an extraction shooter, where everything’s about tension and feeling personally invested, it really breaks the immersion. It’s hard to get hyped about saving ‘a runner’ when it’s not my runner, you know?

Marathon isn’t a poorly made game – the shooting mechanics are good, and matches can be thrilling when they come together. However, the ‘Runner Shells’ system ultimately holds it back. Instead of letting players experiment and build unique characters, it forces them into pre-defined roles, making many items useless if you don’t fit those roles. This lack of freedom is disappointing, and Bungie made a significant misstep with this design choice.

Custom Loadouts Could Restore Player Freedom and Connection

What’s most annoying is that the fix feels pretty straightforward. Instead of locking abilities to specific characters, they could have been implemented as rewards you earn – like loot or gear. Think about being able to choose passive and active skills as equipment options, letting you create a build that’s truly your own. That would give players much more freedom and keep them engaged for a long time. It might require some extra balancing, but ultimately, the goal is to keep people playing, so a little extra work would be worth it.

Games like Cyberpunk 2077 really showcase the potential of truly flexible character building. Instead of choosing from pre-defined classes, the game lets you combine skills and cybernetic enhancements in almost limitless ways, allowing you to create a character that feels uniquely your own. This creates a strong sense of ownership – your character feels like a direct result of your choices, not just a pre-made model.

Marathon comes close to offering real depth, but ultimately falls short. By limiting core gameplay elements to pre-defined character types, it prioritizes simplicity over allowing players to truly customize their experience. While this makes the game easy to understand, it hinders individuality. In a genre that thrives on experimentation and unique playstyles, this feels like a missed opportunity for long-term enjoyment.

While it’s not too late to make changes, Bungie could improve the game after it launches by giving players more freedom to create unique characters instead of being limited to pre-defined options. However, with the release date so near, major overhauls seem unlikely. Marathon has moments of promise, but ultimately feels underwhelming because it doesn’t take the risks needed to make it truly special.

Honestly, I’m a little disappointed. The game gives you set characters instead of letting you create your own, and that feels like a missed opportunity. It’s a shame because the world they’ve built in Marathon is actually pretty cool, but I don’t really get to be anyone in it – I’m just playing as someone. It kind of holds the game back from being truly great, you know?

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

Read More

2026-03-03 01:11