Marvel Just Introduced the Most Tragic Version of a Popular MCU Character

by

For fifteen years, Sebastian Stan has received acclaim for his portrayal of Bucky Barnes, Captain America’s complex and tragic friend. Bucky, who was brainwashed and turned into a Russian assassin known as the Winter Soldier, is a character defined by his struggles and attempts to atone for past mistakes – a story the Marvel Cinematic Universe tells effectively. However, the Marvel Comics version of Bucky Barnes, specifically in the Ultimate Universe, is even more heartbreaking. In this darker universe, ruled by the villain Maker, Bucky became the terrifying Neo-Nazi terrorist, the Grand Skull, and Ultimates #22 finally explains how he underwent this drastic change.

After decades of imprisonment, the Maker has broken free, and Earth’s heroes are now fighting a massive battle to end his oppressive rule. Leading the Maker’s cruel forces is the Red Skull Army, a Neo-Nazi group commanded by the mysterious Grand Skull. Readers first encountered them in Ultimates #10, with early clues suggesting Bucky was the person behind the mask. As the final showdown begins, Captain America—Steve Rogers—must face his former friend, who now embodies everything he stands against.

The Maker’s New World Broke Bucky

What really gets to me about Bucky’s story in the Ultimate Universe is how genuinely human and heartbreaking it is. Issue #22 of Ultimates beautifully shows us not just how Bucky became who he was, but also the deep roots of his friendship with Steve. It’s so different from the traditional timeline where they met during the war. Here, these two are childhood best friends, practically brothers. Steve was always small and sick, and Bucky was always the one looking out for him, protecting him. When the war came around and Steve got the Super Soldier Serum, he immediately wanted to fight with Bucky, to protect him this time. But instead of the tragic fall and brainwashing we’re used to, something far more natural happened: Bucky simply lived a long life. It’s a powerfully realistic and surprisingly moving take on the character.

For decades, everyone believed Captain America was dead, frozen in ice. Meanwhile, Bucky returned home from the war and lived a normal life – unlike what happened to Captain America, he wasn’t captured or experimented on by the Russians. But when a powerful figure known as the Maker seized control of the world and established a dictatorship, Bucky watched the values he’d fought for in World War II disappear. To his dismay, no one else seemed to notice the world changing around them. Over the years, Bucky repeatedly attempted to become a congressman, hoping to make a difference while there was still a government to serve in. However, he could only stand by and watch as democracy faded away.

Following the end of democratic rule, Bucky found work as a car mechanic. But even that was taken from him when the Maker invented self-repairing vehicles. Years later, an aging Bucky was diagnosed with liver cancer. Despite a difficult life, he refused to accept a pointless death. Completely defeated by the Maker’s new world order, Bucky pleaded with Nick Fury, a follower of the Maker, for another chance. Fury agreed, giving Bucky the super-soldier Infinity Formula and assigning him to infiltrate the Red Skulls as their leader, the Grand Skull. However, as time passed, Bucky became increasingly disillusioned and angry, eventually embracing the Red Skulls’ fascist beliefs.

After a long and difficult fight with Steve, who had recently been revived, Bucky was completely broken, both in body and spirit. Decades of isolation and loss had left him a shattered man, pleading for his life. But Steve realized his friend was too far gone to be saved and made the heartbreaking decision to end his suffering. He held Bucky one last time before breaking his neck, granting him peace. This Bucky was different from any other across the multiverse – he was beyond saving and deserved release from his pain.

Bucky’s Descent Is Tragically Realistic

Across different universes, Bucky Barnes is consistently a tragic figure who experiences a descent into darkness. However, the way this happens, and how much control he has over it, varies. In the primary Marvel universe (Earth-616), Bucky didn’t choose to become the Winter Soldier. He was captured after a plane crash, lost his arm, and was then brutally tortured and brainwashed. The Super Soldier Serum and periods of suspended animation kept him alive and young for decades, but he was essentially a puppet, forced to commit terrible acts against his will. As soon as the brainwashing ended, Bucky immediately tried to make amends and become a hero.

Unlike the Bucky we know from the main Marvel Universe, this Bucky from another reality didn’t become a villain through manipulation or a super-soldier program. He chose that path himself, and his story feels particularly relevant today because it’s so believable. He was a soldier left behind by the country he served, and he felt helpless as society changed – with democracy weakening and jobs being lost to artificial intelligence. He also struggled with the fear of his own death, a fear many people share. Ultimately, years of bitterness, loneliness, and feeling powerless led him to embrace beliefs he had previously fought against.

What’s so heartbreaking about this version of Bucky is that, over time and through the manipulations of the Maker, he deliberately abandoned his own values. He did this not to escape his inner demons, but to maintain a sense of control and purpose. Ultimately, he let the darkness consume him entirely, falling so far that even Captain America, his closest friend, believed he was beyond saving. In a genre filled with complex stories of heroes becoming villains, Ultimates #22 presents a particularly realistic, subtle, and tragic portrayal of how anyone, even the strongest among us, can succumb to despair and lose their way.

What do you think? Leave a Comment below and join the conversation in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/the-5-best-new-characters-in-the-ultimate-universe/embed/#

Read More

2026-03-22 17:12