Why Grimm Surpasses Supernatural as TV’s Best Monster Hunter Show

by

It’s hard to overstate how influential Supernatural was on television. Even now, people are still discussing the show about the two brothers who hunted monsters across America, and many fans hope it will return in some form. However, shows like the one on NBC demonstrate that it’s possible to take a similar approach and create something even more compelling.

While Grimm and Supernatural share some similarities, Grimm stands out due to its unique take on monster hunting. Instead of the protagonist simply trying to eliminate every creature he encounters, the show’s case-of-the-week format allows for more complex storytelling, ultimately making it a more compelling series than Supernatural.

Grimm Shares a Lot of Similarities With Supernatural

The TV show Supernatural centered around two brothers who were raised to be monster hunters. Their personal mission began as revenge for their mother’s death, but it grew into something much larger. Over time, they faced increasingly powerful foes, even battling figures from the Bible, with the fate of the world hanging in the balance.

While not as epic in scope as those other shows, Grimm shares some key similarities. The series follows Nick Burkhardt, a Portland police officer who discovers he can see people change into monstrous beings. This ability reveals he’s a Grimm – a descendant of a long line of hunters tasked with tracking and eliminating these creatures, known as wesen.

As a Grimm, Nick is often feared by wesen, and while many are frightening, he discovers that not all of them are evil. He also realizes wesen are deeply connected to society – working in places like the police and government – making a simple ‘hunt them all down’ approach, like the one seen in shows like Supernatural, much more complicated.

Both shows feature mysteries for the main characters to solve, but while the heroes in Supernatural often use deception to find monsters, Nick’s investigations in Grimm consistently lead him to wesen. Although both shows share the theme of heroes discovering the monster, Supernatural expands to a broader, larger scale. However, Grimm compensates for its smaller scope with more engaging and well-developed characters.

Grimm’s Formula Leaves Room for Surprises

Dean and Sam Winchester, the brothers from Supernatural, share many memorable scenes, and their close bond keeps them together. However, beyond major plot twists or a character’s death, it’s rare for the show to offer smaller surprises that don’t significantly affect the overall story.

Grimm follows a successful formula by blending classic police investigations with a fantastical twist. Each episode introduces a new, unique creature – a ‘wesen’ – that Nick Burkhardt hasn’t seen before. As Nick investigates, he learns about this new creature, figures out how to stop it, and connects it to his ongoing police work. This allows for a larger, overarching mystery to unfold throughout the series.

The story gains tension because Nick has to decide whether a situation calls for police work or the unique skills of a Grimm. This is important because, unlike most Grimms who always kill, Nick tries to avoid it. Each episode highlights his empathy and his ability to often turn creatures he encounters into allies rather than enemies.

Okay, so the show definitely has a pattern – you expect certain things to happen in each episode. But honestly, that’s what makes the surprises so good! Like, you think you know what’s coming, and then BAM! The police chief turns out to be one of them, or Nick’s family is about to discover his secret. It’s not about constantly breaking the mold, but smartly choosing when to shake things up and keep you hooked. That’s what I really appreciate about it.

Focusing on strong character development and themes is more effective than forcing the plot forward with unbelievable twists or creating confusing inconsistencies. When the story is carefully constructed, Grimm can really explore its deeper ideas, making the characters more interesting and the overall story more satisfying.

Grimm’s Themes Elevate it Past Supernatural

Unlike Supernatural, which ran for 15 seasons, Grimm had a shorter run, and this allowed it to avoid the common pitfall of losing steam or viewers. Instead, the show made the most of its time by developing its mythology, characters, and core ideas effectively.

Nick was the most interesting character on Grimm because he didn’t fit the typical hunter stereotype. He was, at heart, a police officer and always handled situations as one, even though he had a natural talent for tracking and defeating wesen with weapons like axes and swords. He understood that wesen, just like people, weren’t all evil, and this allowed him to help and befriend them, as seen in his relationship with Monroe.

The show Grimm realistically portrays the complexities of many situations. It uses supernatural events to enhance its storytelling, demonstrating that heroism isn’t limited to human characters.

Throughout the series, Nick faces increasing difficulty balancing his life as a police officer with keeping his supernatural secret hidden from his family. However, these challenges are what make his character so captivating. As Nick confides in more friends and gains their support, he grows both as a cop and as a Grimm, which also makes the show more engaging. While Supernatural still offers plenty of action, Grimm ultimately stands out due to its well-developed storyline and compelling characters. The show explores the complexities of morality, suggesting that doing what’s right isn’t always simple and that questioning tradition can be necessary for the greater good.

Read More

2026-05-27 13:10