The new series, a spin-off of Yellowstone, is a surprising addition to the franchise. Early reviews are sharply divided – it could either be a huge hit like the original, or quickly fade into obscurity. Luke Grimes returns as Kayce Dutton, now working as a U.S. Marshal and leaving the Yellowstone Ranch behind. However, the show faces a challenge with its significantly different format compared to the main Yellowstone series on Paramount+.
Now set in Montana, the story follows Kayce Dutton as he uses his experience as both a cowboy and a Navy SEAL in his new job. He works alongside teammates Pete Calvin, Belle Skinner, Andrea Cruz, and Miles Kittle, and together they must cope with the emotional toll of being the last defense against the area’s violence while also fulfilling their family obligations.
Early reviews for the new series are mixed, currently at 60% on Rotten Tomatoes, but it’s based on only five reviews so far. What’s clear is that this show is a bigger departure from the original Yellowstone than spin-offs like 1883 and 1923. While some, like Ana Dumaraog from ScreenRant, praised the series and acknowledged the risk, they also believe it could be very rewarding.
Both Katie Doll from CBR and Alex Maidy of JoBlo agree that moving a popular character into a standard police procedural might not work. They worry it won’t capture what made Yellowstone so appealing. While many network dramas use this familiar format and can be successful, Marshals might need to attract Yellowstone fans to truly succeed.
CBS
Being the first show spun off from Yellowstone to air on a major network will definitely give Marshals a big start in terms of viewers. However, the show will need to be compelling enough in its early episodes to keep people watching. Viewers who approach Marshals without expecting it to be exactly like Yellowstone might actually enjoy its unique style and story.
Join the newsletter for deeper Marshals analysis
Subscribe to the newsletter for sharper perspective on Marshals and the Yellowstone universe — focused coverage, thoughtful analysis of reviews and character choices, and context that helps fans weigh what really matters.
Just because a show gets mixed reviews from critics doesn’t mean viewers won’t enjoy it. Audiences often find value in movies and TV shows that critics miss, and Marshals might connect with viewers in a way the Yellowstone finale didn’t. Interestingly, the first season of Yellowstone only received a 58% rating from critics initially, meaning Marshals is currently performing better than the show that launched Taylor Sheridan’s popular Paramount universe nearly a decade ago.
Read More
- Best Controller Settings for ARC Raiders
- Meet the cast of Good Omens season 3: All the actors and characters
- Mark Zuckerberg & Wife Priscilla Chan Make Surprise Debut at Met Gala
- Nippon Sangoku Is The Best New Post-Apocalyptic Anime of Spring 2026
- Review: Final Fantasy Tactics: The Ivalice Chronicles (PS5) – Still the Benchmark for Turn-Based Tactics
- 7 Great Marvel Villains Who Are Currently Dead
- FRONT MISSION 3: Remake coming to PS5, Xbox Series, PS4, Xbox One, and PC on January 30, 2026
- Welcome to Demon School! Iruma-kun season 4 release schedule: When are new episodes on Crunchyroll?
- Elon Musk’s Mom Maye Musk Shares Her Parenting Philosophy
- The Boys Season 5 Officially Ends An Era For Jensen Ackles’ Soldier Boy
2026-02-26 00:32