One Year Later, My Hero Academia’s Biggest Plot Twist Is Still Terrible

by

The ending of My Hero Academia has sparked a lot of debate among fans. While the series concluded with generally positive epilogues, many felt the final storyline rushed and didn’t fully resolve all the plot points, leading some to strongly dislike how it ended.

As you’d expect, My Hero Academia tied up some loose ends with surprising plot twists, particularly concerning the villains Shigaraki and All For One. However, that major twist is widely considered the weakest point of the entire story, and continues to negatively impact the series even now.

How My Hero Academia’s Biggest Plot Twist Ruined Its Best Villain

As Izuku and Shigaraki’s fight neared its conclusion, All For One’s lingering consciousness revealed he’d orchestrated Shigaraki’s entire life. He didn’t just give Shigaraki the Decay quirk; he was behind Shigaraki’s very conception, manipulating Kotaro into having him, and even encouraged Kotaro’s abusive behavior, all to ultimately possess Shigaraki’s body.

For years, fans theorized that All For One originally gave Shigaraki his Decay Quirk. This idea felt logical given the story’s hints and All For One’s established personality. The story could have successfully ended the twist there, before moving on to the climax.

The real issue is that this plot twist went too far. While All For One is known for being a meticulous planner, the extent of his control over Shigaraki’s life felt like an exaggerated caricature, making it hard to believe and diminishing the impact of his character.

What’s even more damaging is how this weakens Shigaraki’s character. He was intended to embody the consequences of heroic failure, but by making All For One the source of all his trauma, the story shifts from being about societal flaws to simply being about one villain’s actions.

This alteration weakens Shigaraki’s character by trying to gain sympathy for him at the very end, and it also undermines the story’s attempt to portray a realistically flawed world. Ultimately, it feels like a negative change for the narrative.

My Hero Academia’s Worst Plot Twist Is Only Good For Its Biggest Villain

One positive aspect of the major plot twist in My Hero Academia is how it develops the character of All For One. He’s long been portrayed as a cruel and sadistic villain who enjoys causing pain, and his return for the final story arc has only reinforced that image.

Watching the story unfold, it’s become clear that All For One has been pulling the strings of Shigaraki’s life all along, which really fits with everything that’s been happening recently. But it also makes him seem even more terrifying than before. Now that he’s established as the main villain, I think his eventual defeat is going to be incredibly satisfying.

Even though the plot twist feels forced and harms Shigaraki’s development and the overall story, it did lead to something interesting, so it wasn’t a total waste. It’s barely redeeming, but it’s not completely pointless.

Does My Hero Academia’s Final Twist Ruin Its Ending?

The recent reveal about Shigaraki is so problematic that many fans fear it will completely ruin the ending of My Hero Academia. The final arc already had issues with its pacing and failed to deliver satisfying conclusions to several storylines, and this new twist could be the final straw for many viewers.

Even with its flaws, the story still manages to deliver a satisfying ending to the final battle of My Hero Academia. Shigaraki gets a proper farewell, and All For One’s defeat feels truly rewarding. While the recent revelations weren’t necessary for this outcome, they don’t ultimately ruin the experience as much as some viewers might expect.

The ending of My Hero Academia isn’t ideal, largely because of the surprising turn involving Shigaraki and All For One. This twist complicated what could have been a simple and satisfying conclusion, and even now, looking back, it doesn’t improve the overall impact.

https://comicbook.com/anime/news/fall-2025s-best-anime-celebrates-its-final-fight-with-a-new-tease/embed/#

Read More

2025-11-17 21:13