There’s a lot of discussion among Star Trek fans about where the series is headed, and some believe it might be time to let it end. Current complaints largely focus on the new show, Star Trek: Starfleet Academy. While Star Trek: Strange New Worlds has been well-received for its focus on Captain Pike and his crew, and Star Trek: Lower Decks offers a fun, animated take, many longtime fans consider Starfleet Academy a major misstep and are calling for a pause to the franchise.
A Reddit user sparked a heated discussion by stating they’d be fine if no more Star Trek shows or movies were ever made. The user, who only watched the recent Kelvin Timeline films, felt that nothing new measured up to the original series and suggested it might be time for Star Trek to end. However, the most interesting part of the conversation happened in the comments section, where people began to debate the point.
What Should the Star Trek Franchise Do Next?
The show Star Trek: Starfleet Academy aimed to attract new, younger viewers by depicting the training of future Starfleet officers. However, this approach alienated many longtime fans who didn’t want to see a Star Trek series focused on young characters. This led to heated online debates, with some viewers upset by the show’s attempt to include diverse perspectives – something Star Trek had always done – and others defending it. The resulting conflict overshadowed the show’s actual stories, and it seemed Starfleet Academy was destined to struggle, no matter how well-made it was.
Despite the current direction of the franchise, many fans are hoping for a return to its roots. One Reddit user explained that shorter seasons of only 8-10 episodes don’t allow enough time for character development or exploration of thought-provoking social issues – hallmarks of classic Star Trek. Another fan agreed, stating that the show needs more episodes focused on ethical dilemmas within a limited setting, prioritizing dialogue and philosophical discussion over large-scale action and cinematic visuals. They want a return to the ‘talking heads’ format where characters grapple with complex moral questions.
A Reddit user suggested the current issues with Star Trek aren’t about progressive storylines or diversity – it’s about the connection between the actors. They explained that their wife enjoyed Deep Space Nine, praising Avery Brooks’ performance and the strong chemistry between the cast. While she also liked the original series for its political themes and unique scripts, they both found the newer shows enjoyable but lacking the spark that captivated early Star Trek fans.
One commenter complimented both Strange New Worlds and Lower Decks, calling them solid shows, though not as strong as Deep Space Nine. They also pointed out that current Star Trek series would benefit from more standalone episodes. They believe Star Trek works best when each episode tells a complete story, like a memorable Discovery episode featuring a space whale and a time-reset device. This kind of self-contained narrative allows for strong character development and interesting sci-fi concepts.
A common frustration these days is how streaming services handle TV shows. Fans have long complained about shorter seasons, but one person on Reddit highlighted a bigger issue: it’s no longer easy to simply watch a show when you want to. They pointed out that people are asking themselves, “Is it worth paying for another streaming subscription just for one show?” While they enjoy Star Trek, they question what else Paramount+ offers and whether it justifies the cost.
What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
Read More
- The Super Mario Galaxy Movie: 50 Easter Eggs, References & Major Cameos Explained
- 10 Best Free Games on Steam in 2026, Ranked
- Surprise Isekai Anime Confirms Season 2 With New Crunchyroll Streaming Release
- Why is Tech Jacket gender-swapped in Invincible season 4 and who voices her?
- ‘Project Hail Mary’: The Biggest Differences From the Book, Explained
- Sydney Sweeney’s The Housemaid 2 Sets Streaming Release Date
- Skate 4 – Manny Go Round Goals Guide | All of the Above Sequence
- Preview: Sword Art Online Returns to PS5 as a Darker Open World Action RPG This Summer
- Forza Horizon 6 ‘Prologue’ gameplay
- Joel Kinnaman Claims ‘Peacemaker’ Was His Last Time as Rick Flag Jr. in the DCU
2026-04-11 23:10