The Terror: Devil in Silver Review: Ridley Scott’s Hidden Gem Horror Series Returns

by

At New Hyde Psychiatric Hospital, a small group of remaining patients meets weekly for a book club. In the second episode of the series, the doctor leading the group chooses Ken Kesey’s One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, believing it will resonate with the patients. However, they strongly object to the selection. As Dorry (played by Judith Light) explains, “This book shows us at our absolute worst.”

As a horror fan, I’ve definitely seen my share of haunted hospitals, especially those focusing on psychiatric wards – it’s a trope, really, and one that owes a lot to books like Kesey’s. These days, audiences want two things from these stories: a genuinely unsettling atmosphere and a sensitive portrayal of mental illness. The newest season of The Terror anthology series, streaming on AMC+ and Shudder, really tries to deliver both without losing the weight of its narrative, but sometimes it feels like it’s fighting against itself – a little too eager to scare us and not quite careful enough with its subject matter.

Dan Stevens Makes for a Hearty Reluctant Hero

Riley Stevens, known for his work in horror and psychological thrillers like Legion, Guillermo del Toro’s Cabinet of Curiosities, and Cuckoo, delivers a particularly brave performance in Devil in Silver. He plays Pepper, a man mistakenly committed to New Hyde psychiatric hospital after a scuffle with police. What was meant to be a 72-hour stay stretches into two weeks, leading Pepper to suspect his admission wasn’t a coincidence.

In New Hyde, Pepper encounters a unique and close-knit group of people. Their strong relationships make the story feel familiar and heighten the emotional impact of everything that happens. Pepper acts as the audience’s eyes and ears, experiencing the hospital’s oddities and mysterious history just as we would.

Pepper quickly connects with his new housemate, Coffee (Chinaza Uche), as well as Loochie and Dorry. Together, this unlikely group navigates the strange, supernatural events unfolding within the hospital. Dorry knows more than she lets on, but is hesitant to share what she knows. Chinaza Uche delivers a strong performance as Coffee, providing a much-needed emotional center to the story, especially after a less prominent role in a previous project. Judith Light is chilling as Dorry, even when she appears calm, and her performance is worthy of awards consideration.

The show’s supporting actors bring depth to their roles. The doctors and staff especially do a great job of showing the harsh realities of the healthcare system from multiple perspectives. One of the series’ strengths – thanks to showrunners Chris Cantwell and Victor LaValle, adapting LaValle’s 2012 novel – is that the story isn’t just told from Pepper’s perspective. We see the staff as uncaring through the eyes of the patients, but often, through the staff’s own viewpoints, we understand they’re exhausted and genuinely doing their best.

Devil In Silver Stumbles Around Its Mental Health Theme

The movie relies on disturbing imagery, sudden shocks, and the actual Devil to create tension. For much of the film, the supernatural aspects unfold slowly. The main character, Pepper, spends time trying to understand what’s causing the terror within the hospital, interacting with other patients and staff to piece things together. Even after discovering the source, the film gets bogged down in complexities, struggling to clearly define the evil force and how it works.

The new season of Devil in Silver quickly reveals a disturbing truth: the mental health hospital is severely underfunded and unable to properly care for its patients. The series immediately highlights the hospital’s desperate situation, showing staff resorting to reusing blood-soaked mattresses and docking a nurse’s pay for a minor issue. Between understaffing and patients needing restraints after outbursts, the show powerfully illustrates how the hospital struggles against the challenges of the American healthcare system.

Devil in Silver stands out for its effort to see the individual behind each patient’s illness, though not every character is fully developed. Some, like Coffee, Dorry, and Loochie, receive detailed attention, which is both a strength and a weakness. A recurring theme is characters telling each other they “don’t belong,” not because of the hospital’s chaotic structure, but because they perceive each other as being mentally healthy – as ‘normal’.

This approach unfairly portrays people who genuinely need institutional care. The show often positions those wrongly committed as the only trustworthy characters, while implying that individuals with serious mental illness are untrustworthy. This creates a dangerous narrative where these individuals aren’t seen as victims of a flawed system, but rather as unavoidable casualties. The series walks a fine line with this portrayal, and it’s a concerning pattern.

While the show focuses on Pepper’s growth beyond simply acknowledging and making amends for his past, it doesn’t fully earn the emotional payoff of his ultimate transformation despite the many hardships he endures. However, Devil in Silver delivers a strong and timeless message for American audiences – one that sadly remains relevant today and likely will for years to come. The show suggests that, like the Devil, the true enemy often hides and avoids taking responsibility for wrongdoing.

The Terror: Devil in Silver Is an Exciting Entry

“Devil in Silver” is at its best when tackling serious, real-world problems. While the series’ horror elements can be confusing – the backstory of the Devil is filled with conflicting stories, making it feel like an inconsistent myth – this actually makes encounters with the creature surprisingly satisfying.

The enemy gains strength from the mystery of its own origins. It’s a classic ‘chicken or the egg’ dilemma: did the evil presence arrive because of the hospital’s dark history, or did the hospital become evil because of the presence? To solve this, Pepper needs to do some serious self-reflection, examining his own beliefs and aspirations, which provides a great opportunity for character development.

The film features strong supporting performances from CCH Pounder, Hampton Fluker, and Stephen Root, providing excellent support for the lead actor. While it might seem like a simple monster hunt, the story is actually a compelling psychological drama. It beautifully explores themes of community and self-forgiveness, and includes plenty of horror and creature effects to satisfy genre fans.

The new series, The Terror: Devil in Silver, will begin streaming on AMC+ and Shudder on May 7th, with each episode released every week.

Read More

2026-05-08 00:07