It’s common for adaptations to spark debate about how closely they follow the original story, but Game of Thrones consistently faced more controversy than most. The show famously divided fans of both George R. R. Martin’s books and the TV series, especially with its ending. However, the new series, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms: The Hedge Knight, appeared to be taking a different approach.
From the start, the series has been praised for staying true to George R.R. Martinās book, which showrunner Ira Parker made a key focus. While The Hedge Knight presented several intriguing questions, a significant change from the original novel has reignited discussion about a potentially major shift in the established Game of Thrones storyline.
A Knight of The Seven Kingdomsā Twist is Not What George R.R. Martin Wrote
Now that all the early mysteries were solved and Baelor Targaryen was defeated, the season finale focused on the future of Dunk and Eggās bond. Maekar Targaryen offered Dunk what would have once been a perfect opportunity: knightly training, a royal prince to serve as his squire, and a comfortable life at Summerhall. However, Dunk turned down the offer, feeling heād had enough experience with princes.
Seeing that Egg’s future was in danger, Dunk offered him a way out of the harmful Targaryen family and a chance to travel and learn as he himself had, serving as a squire to Ser Arlan. Though hesitant at first, Maekar eventually agreed, sending Egg to serve under Dunk. This is how the first story in Martin’s collection comes to an end.
The story took an unexpected turn at the very end of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. The finale altered the original book’s plot by adding a brand new scene that shows Maekar never agreed to the plan, and Egg actually escaped against his father’s will. This change is already sparking debate among fans and could create some inconsistencies in the story regarding the prince’s escape.
The Truth: Maekar Doesnāt Actually Give Egg āPermissionā To Squire For Dunk in The Book
Most changes made from the Game of Thrones books were about altering existing scenes or dialogue. However, the final scene in The Hedge Knight doesn’t change anything that happened in the story. Instead, it shows events that likely occurred but weren’t originally described by George R.R. Martin ā scenes he chose to leave untold, rather than changing or removing.
Some readers of the original stories might believe Maekar formally allowed it, but the text doesn’t actually confirm that. Both the book and the TV show feature Dunk making the same request, and Maekarās reluctance is consistent between them. However, Martinās writing in the novellas doesnāt support the idea that Maekar ever gave clear permission.
Readers will likely believe Egg is being honest, even though his own behavior isn’t always perfect. The book also doesn’t disprove the idea that Egg secretly went against his father’s wishes and joined Dunk. It makes sense that Parker has said this possibility will be further investigated in future seasons, adding another layer to Egg’s story without necessarily changing what’s already been established.
Unlike Most Game of Thrones Controversies, This Change Makes The Story Better
Many viewers might initially dislike this change because they believe it hinders Maekar’s character development, which happened off-screen in the book. However, it’s important to consider the new line of dialogue added for the TV series, and how it actually alters our understanding of Maekar’s motivations and intentions.
Dunk effectively demonstrates that Daeron and Aerion represent the potential fate of even the most promising Targaryen heirs. This likely explains why Maekar then confesses his real worry: Egg is his only remaining son. This fear, subtly foreshadowed throughout Spruellās portrayal of Maekar, highlights his conflicting anxieties ā both about Egg leaving and about him staying. However, if the show implies Egg is the one who chooses his path, it significantly improves the storyline.
No matter what happens next in the story of The Hedge Knight, one thing is certain: Eggās choice to leave home and discover the world with Dunk is entirely his own. This makes sense for a character who quickly charmed viewers with his bravery, independent streak, and strong moral compass. Instead of a future decided by Dunk and reluctantly allowed by Maekar, Egg is now actively choosing his path, and his father is accepting of that growth.
Even if the show follows the books closely, giving Egg a more active role adds depth to the narrative. This choiceāhim forging his own path despite his lineageāis central to the themes of The Hedge Knight.
What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
Read More
- How to Get the Bloodfeather Set in Enshrouded
- Gold Rate Forecast
- 4 TV Shows To Watch While You Wait for Wednesday Season 3
- Goat 2 Release Date Estimate, News & Updates
- 32 Kids Movies From The ā90s I Still Like Despite Being Kind Of Terrible
- Best Werewolf Movies (October 2025)
- 10 Movies That Were Secretly Sequels
- One of the Best EA Games Ever Is Now Less Than $2 for a Limited Time
- Auto 9 Upgrade Guide RoboCop Unfinished Business Chips & Boards Guide
- Meet the cast of Mighty Nein: Every Critical Role character explained
2026-02-27 07:10