Netflix’s Mindhunter is Better Than All of Criminal Minds Combined

When crime dramas were hugely popular, Criminal Minds stood out as something new. Instead of just showing how police solve crimes, like many shows at the time, it focused on why criminals do what they do, exploring their psychology. Though it felt unique for network television, it’s important to remember that the series was also influenced by other crime stories in books, movies, and television.

The TV show Criminal Minds owes a lot to the work of John E. Douglas, whose book Mindhunter: Inside the FBI’s Elite Serial Crime Unit was groundbreaking in the field of criminal psychology. Douglas even served as the inspiration for the character Jack Crawford in Thomas Harris’s Hannibal Lecter novels. Mindhunter also inspired the Netflix series of the same name, which explored similar themes but with a unique approach to crime storytelling, particularly how investigators use psychology. Though it premiered after Criminal Minds had already finished its main run, the Netflix series offered a fresh perspective on the genre.

Mindhunter Has Stood the Test of Time

The show wasn’t overly shocking, allowing viewers to still enjoy it. Each hour-long episode concluded with the case being solved, and the FBI agents would then celebrate. While Netflix’s Mindhunter explored the appeal of psychological investigation, it ultimately presented a much more disturbing and complex story. A key distinction between the two shows was the era in which they took place.

Although Criminal Minds featured psychological profiling as a common practice, Mindhunter presented it as something groundbreaking. The Netflix series highlighted how new and surprising the technique was at a time when crime rates were rapidly increasing and overwhelming law enforcement.

Before this, there wasn’t a name for criminals who committed a series of murders without any apparent reason. Law enforcement was confused by the idea of a killer who didn’t have a clear motive, and this lack of understanding highlighted the need for a specialized team to study these types of crimes.

Watching the series really showed me how intense the work of psychological profiling is. I was especially fascinated by Holden Ford, who seemed so driven to understand what makes killers tick – he really wanted to get inside their heads. He believed that by talking to these criminals, he could figure out how to prevent these terrible things from happening again, and I could see how important that was to him.

While other shows explored similar themes, Mindhunter stood out because of its unique visual style. The director brought the same cinematic quality he was known for in films like Se7en and Zodiac – movies that realistically portrayed the dark world of serial killers. This made each episode of the Netflix series feel like a big-budget film.

The first ten episodes of the series really showcased Fincher’s unique filmmaking style, making it stand out from other crime dramas. The show slowly built up the tension and carefully laid the groundwork for the investigation that ultimately led to the capture of several notorious criminals.

The first season ended with Holden understanding that getting too involved in his work – and especially close to the criminals he studied – was incredibly risky. While these discoveries moved the story forward, Mindhunter was primarily focused on the characters and how Holden and his team coped with the disturbing truths they faced.

Mindhunter Continues On Despite Its Cancellation

Mindhunter stood out from many Netflix shows by avoiding simple storylines. It explored challenging and disturbing ideas about what makes people tick, all while being beautifully made. However, these artistic choices may have ultimately played a role in its cancellation.

Despite receiving praise from both critics and viewers, Netflix decided the show was too costly to continue. For reasons unknown, Mindhunter was cancelled, leaving many storylines unfinished. Throughout most of the episodes, viewers also saw short, disturbing scenes featuring a man who looked like Denis Rader, the BTK killer.

Even though it took decades for Rader to be caught, these early moments in the show highlighted the importance of Holden and his team’s work. Mindhunter was critically acclaimed after just one season, and viewers eagerly awaited a second. However, even a second season wasn’t enough, and unlike Criminal Minds, which ran for over a decade, Mindhunter remains indefinitely paused.

This show continues to stay with viewers, leaving them to speculate about what might have happened if it hadn’t been canceled. It’s particularly well-known for its abrupt ending, which many fans found frustrating. Each episode was beautifully crafted, feeling more like a high-quality movie than a typical TV show due to its excellent production and storytelling.

People remember this show not for how many episodes it had – unlike many crime dramas – but for the incredible care and detail put into making it. Two shows can have similar stories, but how those stories are told is what truly matters. That’s why fans are still disappointed about the end of Mindhunter, even after years with no news about its future.

5 Questions
Mindhunter vs. Criminal Minds: Test Your Serial Killer Profiling Smarts
Your Top Score
Attempts
0
0
Report Error

Found an error? Send it so it can be corrected.

Read More

2026-02-28 22:09