Less Than a Year On, Lanterns Just Created a Major Superman Plot Hole

by

The new DC Universe is gaining traction with a growing list of exciting projects planned for release in 2026. In theaters, audiences can look forward to Supergirl, starring Milly Alcock, debuting in June, and a horror-focused Clayface movie in October. On television, the HBO original series Lanterns will offer a dark and dramatic mystery in the style of True Detective, led by showrunner Chris Mundy and writer Tom King. The series will follow the dynamic between experienced Green Lantern Hal Jordan (Kyle Chandler) and new recruit John Stewart (Aaron Pierre), exploring a key moment in the history of the Green Lantern Corps within the DC Universe.

The first trailer for the upcoming movie Lanterns gives fans the best look yet at how Hal and John’s relationship develops. What’s surprising is the trailer’s realistic tone – it seems to be focusing on a down-to-earth mystery rather than big, cosmic action. While there’s a quick, fun reference to the Green Lantern Ch’p, the trailer mostly avoids typical superhero moments, instead highlighting the tension between Hal and John. However, one line of dialogue has worried fans about whether the movie fits with the story of last year’s Superman. Hal tells John he doesn’t talk to other Green Lanterns because they’re “all aliens.” This creates a potential plot problem, since Guy Gardner (played by Nathan Fillion) was a well-known hero appearing publicly in Metropolis in the 2025 film.

Lanterns Doesn’t Have a Plot Hole, We Just Lack the Full Context

The confusion about whether there are other human Green Lanterns in the DC Universe probably isn’t a mistake by the creators, but rather a result of how trailers are made. Trailers often focus on the overall feeling and themes, not necessarily on presenting events in perfect order. So, a single line shouldn’t be taken as a complete explanation of what’s happening. Hal Jordan being dismissive of Guy Gardner could simply be his character reacting based on their complicated history from the comics. It’s also possible Hal is referring to all the alien members of the Green Lantern Corps, not just the few humans who have recently become Lanterns.

The trailer for Lanterns shows Hal Jordan is very possessive of being a Green Lantern and hesitant to accept John Stewart as his successor. This implies Hal’s previous remark about “all aliens” might have been a calculated attempt to discourage John from connecting with others in the Green Lantern Corps. With Nathan Fillion confirmed to be in the series, Lanterns will definitely connect to the earlier movies. The show will likely delve into the reasons behind Hal’s dismissive behavior towards human Lanterns, turning what could have been a plot inconsistency into a deeper look at his character and why he keeps to himself.

Lanterns is currently scheduled to premiere on HBO and HBO Max in August 2026.

What are your thoughts on Guy Gardner’s role in the Lanterns story? Share your opinions in the comments and join the discussion on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/comics/list/10-best-green-lantern-stories-in-dc-comics-history/embed/#

Read More

2026-03-05 23:41