9 Great Supernatural Characters Everyone Forgot About

With 15 seasons, Supernatural featured a huge and much-loved cast, but inevitably some great characters faded into the background. The show, which began in 2005, followed brothers Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean Winchester (Jensen Ackles) as they hunted monsters and encountered other hunters, demons, angels, and everyday people who impacted their lives. While Sam and Dean were central to the story, the supporting characters—those who helped, hindered, or fought them—added important drama. Despite their contributions, these characters aren’t often remembered when fans talk about the series.

Despite constantly changing its villains, allies, and overall story, Supernatural always focused on the battle between good and evil. This often meant characters were firmly placed on one side or the other. Beyond the main characters like Sam and Dean, and a small supporting group, characters would frequently vanish for long periods, or even permanently, only to reappear when the plot needed them. This inconsistency meant that even impactful characters could be forgotten, despite their contributions to the story.

9. Gordon Walker

Gordon Walker (played by Sterling K. Brown) was a vampire hunter who appeared in seasons 2 and 3 of Supernatural. He faced a sad fate when he became a vampire himself. Unlike Sam and Dean, Gordon was a very aggressive hunter, which caused conflict between them. His story demonstrated that hunters didn’t always share the same methods, and even those with similar goals could be a threat to the Winchester brothers.

Gordon’s story reaches a tragic climax when Dixon, a vampire whose family Gordon previously killed, turns him into a vampire himself. While pursuing Sam Winchester, Gordon is ultimately defeated and beheaded after attempting to ambush him. Despite being a fascinating character who offers a unique perspective on the life of a hunter, Gordon appears relatively early in the series and is often overlooked.

8. Max

Though she only appears in a couple of episodes of Supernatural, Max (played by Skylar Radzion) plays a role in the Winchesters’ family history. After taking the Impala for a joyride to impress her girlfriend, Max and her friends are stopped by Sam and Dean. The Impala wasn’t empty – it contained magical objects. When one of these is unleashed, Sam and Dean get a surprising glimpse of their late father, John Winchester (Jeffrey Dean Morgan), as if he were still alive.

Even though Max doesn’t have much screen time, her role in bringing John and Mary Winchester (Samantha Smith) back together makes her a memorable character. She’s also one of the few young LGBTQ+ characters on Supernatural, and it’s great to see her portrayed so authentically, even in a small part.

7. Frank Devereaux

Frank Devereaux, played by Kevin R. McNally, appeared in season 7 of Supernatural. Though he was only in a few episodes, he significantly impacted Sam and Dean’s fight against the Leviathans. They met him through Bobby Singer, who wasn’t particularly welcoming, but Frank’s cautious and saddened demeanor had a reason. A skilled counterfeiter living in hiding, Frank aided the Winchesters, but his role in the show was more about the larger themes than providing direct help.

Like many characters in the show, Frank doesn’t easily trust people in charge, but this becomes a key issue when Sam and Dean need to rely on him. Frank is a darkly funny and unusual character, and his death at the hands of the Leviathans highlights just how dangerous those creatures are to Sam and Dean as they face difficult challenges.

6. Ash

Chad Lindberg plays Ash, a helpful employee at Harvelle’s Roadhouse in seasons 2 and 5 of Supernatural. He adds depth to the world surrounding Ellen and Jo Harvelle. Despite his rough appearance, Ash is incredibly intelligent – he was expelled from MIT for fighting. He uses his technical skills and research abilities to assist hunters in tracking down supernatural creatures, effectively earning his place at the Roadhouse.

Though he doesn’t appear much in Supernatural, Ash is a compelling character for Sam and Dean to meet. After initially handling cases alone in season one, Sam and Dean began discovering a wider world of people who also hunt supernatural creatures. Ash played a significant role in supporting their work and helping them develop as hunters.

5. Kaia Nieves

In season 13 of Supernatural, Kaia Nieves (played by Yadira Guevara-Prip) is introduced, adding dreamwalkers to the story and further developing the characters of Jody Mills (Kim Rhodes) and Claire Novak (Kathryn Newton). Kaia has the ability to see different realities in her dreams, which leads her to team up with Sam and Dean Winchester. However, she soon finds herself struggling as her powers become crucial to opening doorways between worlds.

Alternate realities are a key element of the show Supernatural, particularly in its later seasons. When Kaia arrived and brought her unique abilities, it opened up exciting new possibilities for the story. Although she’s not in many episodes, Kaia’s perspective – being suddenly dropped into a dangerous world without understanding it or knowing how to control her emotions – makes her an ideal character to drive the plot forward.

4. Benny Lafitte

Benny Lafitte (played by Ty Olsson) is a vampire who becomes a close friend to Dean during season 8 of Supernatural, after they’re both stuck in Purgatory. What makes Benny different from most vampires in the show is his desire for forgiveness, not revenge. He fell in love with a human woman after becoming a vampire and chose to break away from the vampire who turned him. This adds a compelling layer to his story, especially considering Dean’s long-held belief that vampires are simply monsters.

Benny’s story shifts after he escapes Purgatory with Dean. He demonstrates his compassion by sacrificing himself to save Sam, proving he’s more than just a monster as he faces death again. Though his quest for revenge is typical for creatures on Supernatural, Benny is memorable because of his strong bond with Dean and his selfless act – a trait usually seen in the show’s heroes.

3. Anna Milton

Anna Milton, played by Julie McNiven, first appeared in season 5 of Supernatural as a fallen angel who had been living as a human. Once she regains her angelic powers, both angels and demons start hunting her, complicating her interactions with Sam and Dean Winchester. Anna provides valuable knowledge about the inner workings of the angels and the coming apocalypse, and her story complements that of the angel Castiel (Misha Collins).

Anna’s storyline, though it takes a dramatic turn when she tries to kill Sam, is important for the progression of Supernatural. Her actions add depth to the angelic world, revealing a complexity viewers hadn’t seen before, and ultimately drive season 4 forward. Anna’s ambiguous behavior creates a compelling and memorable arc.

2. Mick Davies

Mick Davies, played by Adam Fergus, is introduced in season 12 of Supernatural as a member of the British Men of Letters. Initially, he’s presented as a stern and pragmatic character who clashes with Sam and Dean. As the leader of hunting operations in the United States, Mick tries to impose strict rules on the Winchesters, despite their years of experience and established methods.

Sam and Dean manage to gain Mick’s trust when he starts to doubt his organization’s willingness to harm innocent people. Though his character tragically dies, Mick’s story is significant to the overall narrative of Supernatural. He evolves from a villain into someone the audience can support, becoming a more complex and relatable character throughout the series.

1. Donatello Redfield

Donatello Redfield, played by Keith Szarabajka, first appeared in season 11 of Supernatural and continued to appear in later seasons as a prophet. Interestingly, Donatello is an atheist, which makes his role as a prophet unique – he’s not portrayed as a religious character. Throughout the series, he struggles with his newfound divine duties, constantly questioning his own beliefs.

The contrast between Donatello and Sam and Dean is striking for fans of Supernatural, especially considering how readily the Winchester brothers usually accept the supernatural world. Donatello is honest about the burdens of having such a significant role in the universe, and while his negativity can be a lot, his skepticism is often a welcome change. Ultimately, his knack for questioning the established rules of Supernatural‘s complex history is a good thing.

2026-04-19 19:24