The New Lord of the Rings Game May Have Already Dodged the Biggest Open-World Game Trap

by

I was absolutely thrilled to hear that Warhorse Studios is actually making a Lord of the Rings RPG! Last year they said the rumors weren’t true, but now it’s confirmed, and honestly, it’s the best news I’ve had in ages. I’m a huge fan of both The Lord of the Rings and Kingdom Come: Deliverance, and the idea of Warhorse – the team who really nailed the open-world RPG with Kingdom Come – bringing Middle-earth to life has been my dream ever since I first heard the whispers. I truly believe they’re the ones who can finally create a Lord of the Rings game that does Tolkien’s world the justice it deserves.

This isn’t just about creating a big, open world version of Middle-earth. As someone who’s spent a lot of time playing Lord of the Rings Online, I know how immersive that world can be when it feels truly connected. But I’m optimistic about Warhorse Studios’ potential to make a great Lord of the Rings RPG because of what they achieved in Kingdom Come: Deliverance. I really admire their approach to open-world game design, and I believe they’ll stick to that vision instead of falling into the common pitfalls that plague so many other open-world titles.

Warhorse Studios Has Proven It Understands the Value of Discovery

Warhorse Studios has successfully created RPGs that feel realistic and immersive, while remaining fun to play. Their Kingdom Come: Deliverance games particularly stand out for their commitment to historical accuracy, letting players experience medieval Bohemia as it truly was – including the clothing, language, social structures, religious conflicts, and daily challenges of the time. By building such a detailed and believable world, they’ve also demonstrated a strong understanding of how rewarding it is for players to explore and uncover its secrets.

What’s That Weapon? Identify the silhouettes before time runs out.

Easy (7.5s)Medium (5.0s)Hard (2.5s)Permadeath (2.5s)
5.0s
0/10

Results

0

High Score: 0 —

More Games

Kingdom Come: Deliverance isn’t just about the story; it’s about immersing yourself in a believable world. While there is a plot, it focuses on a relatable, down-to-earth character. Henry isn’t meant to be a hero; he’s more like a vessel for the player, letting you experience the richly detailed medieval Bohemia that the developers created. In many ways, the world itself is the star, and you, as Henry, are simply trying to navigate and survive within it.

The developers put a lot of effort into making Bohemia feel like a fully realized world, not just a backdrop for the story. This world feels alive thanks to its realistic characters and the rewarding discoveries players make when they explore beyond the main quest. In fact, the games are designed so the main story doesn’t interrupt exploration, encouraging players to follow their curiosity. This is where the open-world design truly excels – discoveries in Kingdom Come feel meaningful and aren’t just added to make the map bigger.

So Much of What’s Discoverable in a Warhorse World Isn’t Marked on a Map

Many open-world games suffer from feeling like a list of tasks instead of exciting places to explore and uncover secrets. Game maps are often filled with markers telling you exactly where to go and what to do. Developers often do this to avoid making the world feel empty, packing it with activities and collectibles. However, these pointless tasks can actually make the world feel more empty. The key is to use empty space effectively to create a truly engaging experience.

There’s nothing inherently bad about open-world games offering a lot to do. The problem usually lies in how that content is presented. Crimson Desert, for example, has a massive world that could take hundreds of hours to explore, but it doesn’t feel overwhelming. It achieves this by hiding most activities on the map, encouraging players to find them naturally. This lets players explore at their own pace without feeling pressured to complete everything, and it also prevents them from worrying they’re missing out by choosing one path over another.

Kingdom Come: Deliverance is, first and foremost, a world that players can live in.

Warhorse’s Kingdom Come: Deliverance games stand out because they encourage players to explore and discover things naturally, instead of simply following markers on a map. The most rewarding experiences often come from stumbling upon unexpected events – like overhearing a conversation, taking a detour down an intriguing road, accidentally wandering into trouble, or discovering a hidden story through an ordinary character. This approach makes the game world feel alive and independent of the player, which is key to a great open-world RPG.

Warhorse’s Middle-earth RPG May Have Already Avoided the Open-World Trap

Knowing Warhorse’s approach to game development, I’m confident their upcoming Lord of the Rings RPG won’t simply turn Middle-earth into a collection of famous landmarks. It would be easy for a game like this to fall into that trap, especially given how well-known Tolkien’s world is. The temptation to just fill the map with recognizable places and guide players through a checklist of iconic locations is strong. However, if Warhorse applies the same realistic and immersive design principles from Kingdom Come: Deliverance, Middle-earth will likely feel like a truly lived-in world that players gradually discover through exploration, observation, and a natural sense of curiosity, rather than a pre-determined tour.

That’s why I’m so enthusiastic about Warhorse Studios being involved. Open-world RPGs based on The Lord of the Rings often struggle under the weight of the source material, especially when they focus on simply making things bigger or including familiar places instead of creating truly engaging exploration. Warhorse has proven they can create a rich open world without constantly pointing out interesting things to the player, and that’s exactly what a Lord of the Rings game needs. If they approach this new game with the same design philosophy, it could avoid a common pitfall of the genre before anyone even plays it.

Read More

2026-05-21 03:04