29 Years Later, Star Trek Releases a Surprise Sequel to One of Voyager’s Best Episodes

by

This year marks the 60th anniversary of Star Trek, and the new series Starfleet Academy feels like a fitting tribute. Though set almost 300 years in the future, the show is filled with nods to classic episodes. We’ve already seen continuations of stories from The Next Generation, familiar faces from Deep Space Nine, and even Robert Picardo reprising his role as the Doctor – still going strong nearly 900 years after his adventures in the Delta Quadrant.

The eighth episode of Starfleet Academy, titled “The Life of the Stars,” takes a different approach by exploring the emotional aftermath of a battle between the students and terrifying alien creatures called the Furies. It also addresses a puzzling question from earlier in the season: why the Doctor is reluctant to help SAM, a holographic being who asked him to be her mentor. The explanation, surprisingly, connects to a memorable episode from Voyager.

The Doctor Is Still Wounded After One Of Voyager’s Best Stories

As a huge Trek fan, I’ve always loved how the show explores what it means to be human, and it often does that through characters who aren’t human themselves. Spock really started that trend, but Commander Data is the one everyone thinks of. So, when Voyager introduced the Doctor, it felt natural that he’d be going through that same journey. It’s especially clear in the Season 3 episode, “Real Life.” He wanted to build a holographic family, thinking it would help him connect with his patients. At first, he created this overly sweet, perfect family, but B’Elanna Torres helped him add some realistic unpredictability into the mix, which was exactly what he needed.

Honestly, this episode, “Real Life,” is a standout – many fans, including myself, consider it one of the very best of Season 3, and one of the greatest holodeck episodes Star Trek has ever done. A huge part of that is thanks to Andrew Robinson’s incredible performance as Garak. He’s just brilliant, moving seamlessly between funny moments and heartbreaking drama. It starts out lighthearted, with Garak hilariously struggling to understand human customs, but then things take a really dark turn. His ‘daughter,’ Belle, gets seriously hurt, and it’s devastating – even the Doctor, with all his advanced knowledge, can’t save her. It’s a truly powerful and emotional episode.

In the episode, the Doctor initially tries to avoid dealing with his strong emotions. It’s Tom Paris who convinces him to re-enter the simulation, allowing him to be with his daughter and family as she passes away. Interestingly, his family is never shown again after this event. While he was present for Belle’s death, he doesn’t revisit them in the simulation. This is especially poignant considering Paris warned the Doctor that he can’t fully experience being human unless he allows himself to feel both joy and sorrow.

Starfleet Academy Finally Sees the Doctor Embrace the Consequences of “Real Life”

That’s where Sam comes into the story. The Doctor didn’t reciprocate her romantic feelings because he knew it would inevitably lead to sadness and loss – something he’s avoided for over 800 years. This explains his strong reaction when she hoped he’d become her mentor. However, in episode 8, the Doctor is forced to face his tendency to avoid pain and ultimately decides to overcome his fear and allow himself to connect with someone again.

Let me tell you, it’s not always easy watching, but it’s so worth it. Robert Picardo is just incredible – he’s become an even more powerful actor since his days on Voyager. The episode immediately grabs you with a personal log from the Doctor instead of the usual captain’s log, but the moment that really got to me was when SAM asked him to hold her hand during monitoring. Picardo absolutely nailed it, showing the Doctor as someone deeply emotional and genuinely struggling with his own mortality. Even Chancellor Ake seemed taken aback by his actions in that scene – it was truly powerful.

Ultimately, the Doctor chooses to embrace life. He clearly explains why he hesitated to connect with SAM, helping viewers understand his motivations. It’s a fantastic scene that satisfyingly concludes a storyline from Voyager that deserved to be further explored after the episode “Real Life.” This makes the episode one of the most emotionally impactful of Starfleet Academy so far, despite a few odd subplots, much like the original Voyager installment.

What are your thoughts on Starfleet Academy? Share your opinion in the comments and join the discussion on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/feature/star-trek-just-made-its-new-era-the-most-exciting-in-the-entire-franchises-history/embed/#

Read More

2026-02-26 18:12