Sullivan’s Crossing Season 4 Review: The CW’s Drama Still Feels Like Home Despite Scott Patterson’s Exit

by

The third season of Sullivan’s Crossing left viewers on the edge of their seats with the unexpected arrival of a man claiming to be Maggie’s husband. However, the real concern for the show’s future came when Scott Patterson, an actor on the CW drama, decided to leave. Fortunately, season 4 of Sullivan’s Crossing still manages to feel familiar and comforting, even with Sully no longer part of the story.

In March 2026, the team behind Sullivan’s Crossing announced that actor Patterson wouldn’t be back for season four as Harry Sullivan. The storyline explained that his character had moved to Ireland with Helen Culver (Kate Vernon), leaving the possibility of a future return. However, Patterson later revealed he left the show due to disagreements about the creative direction, suggesting he didn’t plan to reprise his role.

The characters on Sullivan’s Crossing are still dealing with Sully’s departure, but the show is moving forward. Season 4 shifts the focus to the relationships and personal journeys that fans love. After seeing the first two episodes, it’s clear that new characters combined with familiar faces make this season the strongest one yet.

Sullivan’s Crossing Season 4 Is As Quiet & Cozy As Ever

With its comforting theme song, “Time and Time Again” by WILD, and beautiful scenery, season 4 of Sullivan’s Crossing feels like reconnecting with someone you’ve known forever. The show maintains its gentle and cozy atmosphere, offering viewers a relaxing escape in a TV landscape often filled with intense and draining programs. It’s a haven not just for the characters on screen, but for anyone watching.

Season 4 of Sullivan’s Crossing doubles down on what it does best: showcasing the charm of small-town life. While the two leads, Dr. Maggie Sullivan (Morgan Kohan) and Cal Jones (Chad Michael Murray), originally came from the city, theyā€™ve found peace by embracing a slower pace of life. Both Kohan and Murray deliver strong performances as characters learning to live more mindfully and purposefully as they adjust to the calmer atmosphere of the Crossing.

After watching the first couple of episodes of Sullivan’s Crossing season 4, I totally get why Maggie’s dreaming of opening that family practice in Timberlake. Honestly, the way they show small-town life, it’s justā€¦charming. It doesn’t feel cheesy or forced at all, and it actually makes me want to pack my bags and move there myself! Itā€™s a really appealing escape from the hustle and bustle of city life, and you can see why sheā€™d trade being a neurosurgeon for it.

Relationship Drama Doesn’t Disappoint In Sullivan’s Crossing Season 4

Even though Sullivan’s Crossing isn’t a fast-paced show, it’s far from dull. The first two episodes of the new season are full of romantic complications. The show quickly reveals the connection between Maggie and Liam (Marcus Rosner), and immediately explores how his presence could impact her relationship with Cal. While a hidden husband storyline can sometimes feel predictable, Sullivan’s Crossing presents a unique and engaging twist on the familiar trope.

Fans have seen Maggie caught in a love triangle before, with Cal and her ex, Andrew Mathews. However, the new dynamic with Liam feels different. Unlike Andrew, who often frustrated viewers with his actions, Liam seems genuinely likable and sympathetic. It’s also intriguing to see how Maggie reacts to Liam showing up at the Crossing, especially considering her past feelings for him. While the idea of a secret husband isn’t new, the details of Maggie and Liam’s relationship are a surprising twist.

Several of the main couples in Sullivan’s Crossing face challenges. Sydney Shandon and Rafe Vadas disagree about marriage, causing tension in their relationship. Meanwhile, Lola Gunderson and Jacob Cranebear are still navigating the difficulties of their long-distance relationship, which started when Jacob had to move to Alberta for graduate school.

Even the strongest couple on Sullivan’s Crossing, Edna and Frank Cranebear, hit a rough patch when Frank becomes overly protective of Edna as she recovers from brain surgery. Despite this, their loving relationship remains a highlight of the show. A welcome change from other storylines, season 4 realistically portrays the challenges of recovering from a serious illness, showing both the physical and emotional difficulties Edna faces instead of a quick and unrealistic recovery.

Season 4 of Sullivan’s Crossing focuses heavily on family as the Shandons, Rob, and Sydney work together to launch their new restaurant. Rob also faces a tough choice when his son, Finn, gets a life-changing opportunity.

One of the best parts of Sullivan’s Crossing season 4 is the positive relationship between Maggie, Lola, and Sydney. Unlike earlier seasons, which focused on conflict, this season shows a strong and supportive female friendship. Williamson delivers a particularly compelling performance as a more vulnerable Lola, adding depth to her character. The show beautifully illustrates that women can be allies and lift each other up, rather than being pitted against one another.

New Characters Integrate Naturally Into Sullivan’s Crossing Season 4

With Sully departing Timberlake, some fresh faces have joined the show. These new characters fit right in with the existing cast, feeling organic and not forced. Some viewers worried Liam might dominate the storyline, but Rosnerā€™s performance actually enhances the show without stealing the spotlight. In fact, Liam is a welcome addition to Sullivanā€™s Crossing, revitalizing the series and bringing out a different side of Maggieā€™s personality.

Colby Frost joins the cast as Ben Nelson, a young man responsible for helping with his sister, Tracy (played by Emerson MacNeil). Jonathan Silverman plays Quincy Carlson, an unhappy camper. Frost delivers a nuanced performance as Ben, skillfully showing the contrast between what Ben says and what he truly feels through subtle facial expressions, creating a sense of inner conflict for the character.

Jeff Silverman, a talented comedic actor, plays the grumpy character Quincy and adds some much-needed humor to the show. While he’s great at providing comic relief, his story also contributes meaningfully to the plot. Each character feels fresh and authentic, and none of their additions feel unnatural or out of place.

The first two episodes of Sullivan’s Crossing season 4 show a real improvement for the series, suggesting it’s finally hitting its stride after three seasons. While previous seasons were sometimes criticized for weak plots and frustrating character choices, season 4 starts strong, leaving viewers engaged and eager to see what happens next. Sullivan’s Crossing seems to be turning a corner and heading in a positive direction.

Season 4 of Sullivan’s Crossing premieres on The CW with new episodes airing Mondays at 8 p.m. Eastern Time, beginning April 20th.

Read More

2026-04-18 23:29